In 2016, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) promulgated separate regulations intended to control "methane emissions" at crude oil and natural gas production facilities. Some stakeholders have argued that the EPA and BLM rules are duplicative and outside of the agencies' statutory authorities. The BLM rule was eligible for consideration under the Congressional Review Act, and on February 3, 2017, the House passed a joint resolution of disapproval (H.J.Res. 36) to repeal it. The Senate rejected the motion to proceed to H.J.Res. 36 on May 10, 2017, effectively ending Congress's efforts. Any attempts to revisit the rules now turn to the agencies, as the Trump Administration has vowed to review and, if appropriate, "suspend, revise, or rescind" both rules under Executive Order 13783.
Below is a brief discussion of the two rules, their similarities, and their differences.
EPA's "Oil and Natural Gas Sector: Emission Standards for New, Reconstructed, and Modified Sources, Final Rule" (81 Federal Register 35824, June 3, 2016) was promulgated under the authority of the Clean Air Act, as amended (CAA; 42 U.S.C. §7401 et seq.). CAA Section 111 requires EPA to establish a list of source categories to be regulated and emission standards for those source categories. Specifically, CAA Section 111(b)(1)(A) requires that a source category be included on the list if "in [the EPA Administrator's] judgment it causes, or contributes significantly to, air pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare." Once a source category is listed, CAA Section 111(b)(1)(B) requires that the EPA propose and then promulgate "standards of performance" for new sources in the source category. CAA Section 111(a)(1) defines "a standard of performance" as an "emission limitation achievable through the application of the best system of emission reduction which [taking into account the cost of achieving such reduction and any non-air-quality health and environmental impact and energy requirement] the Administrator determines has been adequately demonstrated."
BLM's "Waste Prevention, Production Subject to Royalties, and Resource Conservation, Final Rule" (81 Federal Register 83008, November 18, 2016) was promulgated under the authority of the Mineral Leasing Act of 1920, as amended (30 U.S.C. §181 et seq.). Section 225 of the act requires BLM to ensure that lessees "use all reasonable precautions to prevent waste of oil or gas developed in the land," and, under Section 187, that leases include "a provision that such rules ... for the prevention of undue waste as may be prescribed by [the] Secretary shall be observed."
Since natural gas that is vented, flared, or leaked from crude oil and natural gas production, processing, and transmission activities can be defined as both "air pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or welfare" and "undue waste," EPA and BLM have promulgated rules to control for it under their respective statutory authorities.
EPA's rule targets natural gas emissions for the control of methane pollution (the primary component of natural gas and a potent greenhouse gas). EPA's rule sets standards of performance for methane emissions from several types of new, reconstructed, or modified facilities in the oil and gas production sector. EPA estimates that the rule would reduce methane emissions by 510,000 tons in 2025 and yield climate benefits of $690 million in 2025 (in 2012 dollars), outweighing the estimated costs of $530 million.
BLM's rule targets natural gas emissions as a potential waste of public resources and loss of royalty revenue. BLM's rule requires operators of crude oil and natural gas facilities on federal and Indian lands to take various actions to reduce the waste of gas, establishes clear criteria for when flared gas will qualify as waste and therefore be subject to royalties, and clarifies which on-site uses of gas are exempt from royalties. BLM estimates that the rule would avoid an estimated 175,000-180,000 tons of methane emissions per year and yield total benefits from $209 million to $403 million per year, outweighing the estimated costs of $110-$275 million per year. BLM estimates annual royalties to the federal government, tribal governments, states, and private landowners to increase by $3-$10 million per year.
Some stakeholders have argued that EPA's and BLM's rules are duplicative. Several similarities exist between the two, including the following:
Others point to differences between the two rules, including the following: