Defense Primer: Directed-Energy Weapons




Updated May 18, 2023
Defense Primer: Directed-Energy Weapons
Both the 2022 National Defense Strategy and the House
Directed-Energy Weapons Programs
Armed Services Committee’s bipartisan Future of Defense
A number of countries are investing in directed-energy
Task Force Report have identified directed energy as a
weapons programs. This In Focus discusses a selection of
technology that could have a significant impact on U.S.
unclassified DE weapons programs in three leading military
national security in the years to come. As the Department of
powers: the United States, China, and Russia.
Defense (DOD) continues to invest in directed-energy (DE)
weapons, Congress may consider implications for defense
United States
authorizations, appropriations, and oversight.
DOD requested approximately $1 billion for unclassified
DE programs in FY2024. (For additional information about
Overview
specific U.S. DE weapons programs, see CRS Report
DOD defines DE weapons as those using concentrated
R44175, Navy Lasers, Railgun, and Gun-Launched Guided
electromagnetic energy, rather than kinetic energy, to
Projectile: Background and Issues for Congress, by Ronald
“incapacitate, damage, disable, or destroy enemy
O'Rourke, and CRS Report R45098, U.S. Army Weapons-
equipment, facilities, and/or personnel.” DE weapons
Related Directed Energy (DE) Programs: Background and
include high-energy lasers (HEL) and high-powered
Potential Issues for Congress, by Andrew Feickert.) DOD
microwave (HPM) weapons; other DE weapons, such as
does not currently have any DE programs of record.
particle beam weapons, are outside the scope of this In
Focus.
DOD directed energy programs are coordinated by the
Principal Director for Directed Energy within the Office of
HELs might be used by ground forces in short-range air
the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and
defense (SHORAD), counter-unmanned aircraft systems
Engineering (OUSD[R&E]). The Principal Director for
(C-UAS), or counter-rocket, artillery, and mortar (C-RAM)
Directed Energy is additionally responsible for
missions. The weapons might be used to “dazzle” (i.e.,
development and oversight of the Directed Energy
temporarily disable) or damage satellites and sensors. This
Roadmap. According to OUSD(R&E), DOD’s current DE
could in turn interfere with intelligence-gathering
roadmap outlines DOD’s plan to increase power levels of
operations; military communications; and positioning,
DE weapons from around 150 kilowatts (kW—a unit of
navigation, and timing systems used for weapons targeting.
power), as is currently feasible, to 300 kW by FY2023,
In addition, HELs could theoretically provide options for
“with goal milestones to achieve 500 kW class with
boost-phase missile intercept, given their speed-of-light
reduced size and weight by FY2025 and to further reduce
travel time; however, experts disagree on the affordability,
size and weight and increase power to MW [megawatt]
technological feasibility, and utility of this application.
levels by FY2026.” For reference, although there is no
consensus regarding the precise power level that would be
In general, HELs might offer lower costs per shot and—
needed to neutralize different target sets, some analysts
assuming access to a sufficient power supply—deeper
believe that lasers of around 100 kW could engage
magazines compared with traditional munitions. (Although
unmanned aircraft systems, small boats, rockets, artillery,
a number of different types of HELs exist, many of the
and mortars, whereas lasers of around 300 kW could
United States’ current programs are solid state lasers, which
additionally engage cruise missiles flying in certain profiles
are fueled by electrical power. As a result, the cost per shot
(i.e., flying across—rather than at—the laser). Lasers of 1
is equivalent to the cost of the electrical power required to
MW could potentially neutralize ballistic missiles and
fire the shot.) This could in turn produce a favorable cost-
hypersonic weapons.
exchange ratio for the defender, whose marginal costs
would be significantly lower than those of the aggressor.
In addition to the DE roadmap, OUSD(R&E) manages the
High Energy Laser Scaling Initiative (HELSI), which
Similarly, HPM weapons could provide a nonkinetic means
former Principal Director for Directed Energy Dr. Jim
of disabling adversary electronics and communications
Trebes notes is “to demonstrate laser output power scaling
systems. These weapons could potentially generate effects
while maintaining or improving beam quality and
over wider areas than HELs, which emit a narrower beam
efficiency.” HELSI is intended to strengthen the defense
of energy. As a result, some analysts have noted that HPM
industrial base for potential future directed energy weapons
weapons might provide more effective area defense against
by providing near-term prototyping opportunities for
missile salvos and swarms of drones. HPM weapons have
industry partners. Dr. Trebes additionally notes that
also been considered for use as nonlethal “heat ray”
OUSD(R&E) has completed a DOD-wide Laser Lethality
systems for crowd control.
Analysis Process Review to identify future needs for the
Department and best practices for DE development and use.
According to OUSD(R&E), DOD is also testing a Directed
https://crsreports.congress.gov

Defense Primer: Directed-Energy Weapons
Energy Lethality Database that is to serve as a searchable
weapons, in contrast, are not affected by these factors.
repository for the department’s DE analyses.
How, if at all, might HEL limitations be mitigated by
technological developments, concepts of operation, or other
China
methods? What impact might a failure to mitigate these
According to the U.S.-China Economic and Security
limitations have on future military operations?
Review Commission, China has been developing DE
weapons since at least the 1980s and has made steady
Mission Utility
progress in developing HPM and increasingly powerful
Given the strengths and weaknesses of DE weapons, DOD
HELs. China has reportedly developed a 30-kilowatt road-
is continuing to examine their role within the military. DOD
mobile HEL, LW-30, designed to engage unmanned aircraft
is additionally conducting multiple utility studies to analyze
systems and precision-guided weapons. Reports indicate
potential concepts of operation for DE weapons and to
that China is also developing an airborne HEL pod.
assess the scenarios in which they might be militarily
useful. How might Congress draw upon the conclusions of
According to the Defense Intelligence Agency, China is
these analyses as it conducts oversight of DE weapons
additionally pursuing DE weapons
programs? What is the appropriate balance between DE
weapons and traditional munitions within the military’s
to disrupt, degrade, or damage satellites and their
portfolio of capabilities?
sensors and possibly already has a limited
capability to employ laser systems against satellite
Defense Industrial Base
sensors. China [has likely fielded] a ground-based
Some analysts have expressed concerns that, in the past,
laser weapon that can counter low-orbit space-
DOD did not provide stable funding for DE weapons
based sensors ... and by the mid-to-late 2020s, it
programs or sufficient opportunities for the DE workforce.
may field higher power systems that extend the
According to OUSD(R&E), HELSI is intended to address
threat to the structures of non-optical satellites.
these concerns by providing industry with assured
prototyping opportunities. In what ways, if any, has HELSI
Russia
strengthened the defense industrial base for DE weapons?
Russia has been conducting DE weapons research since the
What, if any, challenges does the base continue to face and
1960s, with a particular emphasis on HELs. Russia has
how might they be mitigated?
reportedly deployed the Peresvet ground-based HEL with
Intelligence Requirements
several mobile intercontinental ballistic missile units.
Although little is publicly known about Peresvet, including
Some analysts have questioned whether DOD has sufficient
its power level, some analysts assert it is to dazzle satellites
knowledge of adversary DE weapons systems and materials
and provide point defense against unmanned aircraft
to develop its weapons requirements. DOD is currently
systems. Russia’s deputy defense minister Alexei
attempting to further define its DE collection requirements
Krivoruchko has stated that efforts are underway to increase
for the intelligence community (IC) through the Directed
Peresvet’s power level and to deploy it on military aircraft.
Energy Lethality Intelligence initiative. To what extent, if at
Reports suggest that Russia may also be developing HPMs
all, is this initiative improving connectivity between DOD’s
as well as additional HELs capable of performing anti-
DE community and the IC? What collection requirements,
satellite missions.
if any, remain?
Potential Issues and Questions for
Coordination within DOD
Congress
Pursuant to Section 219 of the FY2017 National Defense
Authorization Act (P.L. 114-328), OUSD(R&E)’s Principal
Technological Maturity
Director for Directed Energy is tasked with coordinating
Directed-energy weapons programs continue to face
DE efforts across DOD and with developing DOD’s
questions about their technological maturity, including the
Directed Energy Roadmap, which is to guide development
ability to improve beam quality and control to militarily
efforts. To what extent are the military departments and
useful levels and the ability to meet size, weight, and power
defense agencies adhering to this roadmap? What, if any,
(SWaP) and cooling requirements for integration into
additional authorities or structural changes would be
current platforms. Some DE systems are small enough to fit
required to ensure proper coordination throughout DOD?
on military vehicles, but many require larger and/or fixed
platforms that could potentially limit deployment options
Related CRS Products
and operational utility. In what ways, if any, are DOD
CRS Report R46925, Department of Defense Directed Energy
technology maturation efforts reducing the SWaP and
Weapons: Background and Issues for Congress, coordinated by
cooling requirements of DE systems?
Kelley M. Sayler.
Weapons Characteristics
This report was originally co-authored by John Hoehn.
Although HELs may offer a lower cost per shot than
traditional weapons such as missiles, they are also subject
to a number of limitations. For example, atmospheric
Kelley M. Sayler, Analyst in Advanced Technology and
conditions (e.g., rain, fog, obscurants) and SWaP and
Global Security
cooling requirements can limit the range and beam quality
IF11882
of HELs, in turn reducing their effectiveness. Traditional
https://crsreports.congress.gov

Defense Primer: Directed-Energy Weapons


Disclaimer
This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan shared staff to
congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and under the direction of Congress.
Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public understanding of information that has
been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the
United States Government, are not subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be
reproduced and distributed in its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include
copyrighted images or material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you
wish to copy or otherwise use copyrighted material.

https://crsreports.congress.gov | IF11882 · VERSION 8 · UPDATED