Turkey (Türkiye): Major Issues and U.S. Relations

Changes from December 17, 2021 to December 30, 2021

This page shows textual changes in the document between the two versions indicated in the dates above. Textual matter removed in the later version is indicated with ~~red strikethrough~~ and textual matter added in the later version is indicated with blue.

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief December December 1730, 2021 , 2021
U.S. relations with Turkey take place within a complicated environment featuring several U.S. relations with Turkey take place within a complicated environment featuring several
bilateral, regional, and Turkish domestic considerations. Recent tensions have raised questions bilateral, regional, and Turkish domestic considerations. Recent tensions have raised questions
Jim Zanotti
about the future of bilateral relations and have led to U.S. actions against Turkey, including about the future of bilateral relations and have led to U.S. actions against Turkey, including
Specialist in Middle Specialist in Middle
sanctions and informal congressional holds on major new arms sales. Nevertheless, both sanctions and informal congressional holds on major new arms sales. Nevertheless, both
Eastern Affairs Eastern Affairs
countries’ officials emphasize the importance of continued U.S.-Turkey cooperation and countries’ officials emphasize the importance of continued U.S.-Turkey cooperation and

Turkey’s membership in NATO. The following are key factors in the U.S.-Turkey relationship. Turkey’s membership in NATO. The following are key factors in the U.S.-Turkey relationship.
Clayton Thomas
Erdogan’s rule and Turkey’s
Analyst in Middle Eastern Analyst in Middle Eastern
currency crisis. Many observers voice concerns about the largely Many observers voice concerns about the largely
Affairs Affairs
authoritarian rule of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. One of his biggest challenges is authoritarian rule of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. One of his biggest challenges is

Turkey’s economy: Turkey’s economy: ~~an ongoing~~a currency crisis that accelerated in late 2021 has currency crisis that accelerated in late 2021 has ~~exacerbated some~~
~~existing structural economic problems, generating~~generated major domestic concern. major domestic concern. AsWith the country the country ~~faces~~

facing significant inflation, Erdogan significant inflation, Erdogan ~~has~~ pressured Turkey’s central bank pressured Turkey’s central bank to lower interest rates—a to lower interest rates—a
response counter to conventional economic theory. response counter to conventional economic theory. ~~Also, he is unlikely to respond to opposition politicians’ call~~In December, he announced measures aimed at alleviating domestic concerns about the cost of living that may largely simulate interest rate hikes. While Turkey’s currency regained some of the ground it had lost against the dollar, its future financial stability remains unclear. Key opposition politicians have called for early for early
elections (the next presidential and parliamentary elections are scheduled for June 2023) to address growing public discontentelections (the next presidential and parliamentary elections are scheduled for June 2023) to address growing public discontent
~~about the spiraling cost of living. If economic turmoil fuels domestic instability, Erdogan’s cabinet could conceivably initiate~~
~~a state of emergency with the potential to delay elections~~, and Erdogan might schedule them if he perceives an advantage in doing so. Additionally, some observers debate whether free and fair elections . Additionally, some observers debate whether free and fair elections
could take place under Erdogan or whether disgruntled Erdogan supporters would actually vote for opposition parties. could take place under Erdogan or whether disgruntled Erdogan supporters would actually vote for opposition parties.
Separately, some sources have questioned Erdogan’s health. Separately, some sources have questioned Erdogan’s health.
Russian S-400 purchase and U.S. responses. Turkey’s acquisition of a Russian S-400 surface-to-air defense system in July Turkey’s acquisition of a Russian S-400 surface-to-air defense system in July
2019 has had significant repercussions for U.S.-Turkey relations, leading to Turkey’s removal from the F-35 Joint Strike 2019 has had significant repercussions for U.S.-Turkey relations, leading to Turkey’s removal from the F-35 Joint Strike
Fighter program. In December 2020, the Trump Administration imposed sanctions on Turkey’s defense procurement agency Fighter program. In December 2020, the Trump Administration imposed sanctions on Turkey’s defense procurement agency
for the S-400 transaction under the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA, P.L. 115-44).for the S-400 transaction under the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA, P.L. 115-44).
The continuing U.S.-Turkey impasse over the S-400 could prevent major Western arms sales to Turkey. In late 2021, Turkey The continuing U.S.-Turkey impasse over the S-400 could prevent major Western arms sales to Turkey. In late 2021, Turkey
requested some new U.S.-origin F-16s and upgrades to others in its aging fleet. Some Members of Congress oppose the F-16 requested some new U.S.-origin F-16s and upgrades to others in its aging fleet. Some Members of Congress oppose the F-16
transactions, partly due to the S-400 issue. If Turkey cannot partner with the United States to modernize its fighter aircraft, it transactions, partly due to the S-400 issue. If Turkey cannot partner with the United States to modernize its fighter aircraft, it
could turn to Russia or other alternative suppliers. If Turkey transitions to Russian weapons platforms with multi-decade could turn to Russia or other alternative suppliers. If Turkey transitions to Russian weapons platforms with multi-decade
lifespans, it is unclear how it can stay closely integrated with NATO on defense matters. lifespans, it is unclear how it can stay closely integrated with NATO on defense matters.
Turkey’s strategic orientation and U.S./NATO basing. Traditionally, Turkey has relied closely on the United States and Traditionally, Turkey has relied closely on the United States and
NATO for defense cooperation, European countries for trade and investment, and Russia and Iran for energy imports. NATO for defense cooperation, European countries for trade and investment, and Russia and Iran for energy imports.
Turkey’s ongoing economic struggles highlight the risks it faces in jeopardizing these ties. A number of complicated Turkey’s ongoing economic struggles highlight the risks it faces in jeopardizing these ties. A number of complicated
situations in Turkey’s surrounding region—including those involving Syria, Greece, Cyprus, and Libya—affect its situations in Turkey’s surrounding region—including those involving Syria, Greece, Cyprus, and Libya—affect its
relationships with the United States and other key actors, as Turkey seeks a more independent foreign policy. Additionally, relationships with the United States and other key actors, as Turkey seeks a more independent foreign policy. Additionally,
President Erdogan’s concerns about maintaining his parliamentary coalition with Turkish nationalists may partly explain his President Erdogan’s concerns about maintaining his parliamentary coalition with Turkish nationalists may partly explain his
actions in some of the situations mentioned above. actions in some of the situations mentioned above.
In addition to the S-400 transaction, Turkey-Russia cooperation has grown in some areas in recent years. However, Turkish In addition to the S-400 transaction, Turkey-Russia cooperation has grown in some areas in recent years. However, Turkish
efforts (especially during 2020) to counter Russia in several theaters of conflict at relatively low cost—using domestically efforts (especially during 2020) to counter Russia in several theaters of conflict at relatively low cost—using domestically
produced drone aircraft and Syrian mercenaries—suggest that Turkey-Russia cooperation is situational rather than produced drone aircraft and Syrian mercenaries—suggest that Turkey-Russia cooperation is situational rather than
comprehensive in scope. comprehensive in scope.
Turkey’s tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean with countries such as the Republic of Cyprus (ROC) and Greece have Turkey’s tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean with countries such as the Republic of Cyprus (ROC) and Greece have
negatively influenced its relations with several countries in the region, some of whom (such as the ROC, Greece, Israel, and negatively influenced its relations with several countries in the region, some of whom (such as the ROC, Greece, Israel, and
Egypt) have grown closer as a result. In this context, some observers have advocated that the United States explore Egypt) have grown closer as a result. In this context, some observers have advocated that the United States explore
alternative basing arrangements for U.S. and NATO military assets in Turkey. Turkey has made some headway in softening alternative basing arrangements for U.S. and NATO military assets in Turkey. Turkey has made some headway in softening
tensions with some Middle Eastern governments—most notably the United Arab Emirates—in late 2021. tensions with some Middle Eastern governments—most notably the United Arab Emirates—in late 2021.
Outlook and U.S. options. Congressional and executive branch action on arms sales, sanctions, or military basing regarding Congressional and executive branch action on arms sales, sanctions, or military basing regarding
Turkey and its rivals could have implications for bilateral ties, U.S. political-military options in the region, and Turkey’s Turkey and its rivals could have implications for bilateral ties, U.S. political-military options in the region, and Turkey’s
strategic orientation and financial well-being. How closely to engage Erdogan’s government could depend on U.S. strategic orientation and financial well-being. How closely to engage Erdogan’s government could depend on U.S.
perceptions of his popular legitimacy, likely staying power, and the extent to which a successor might change his policies in perceptions of his popular legitimacy, likely staying power, and the extent to which a successor might change his policies in
light of geopolitical, historical, and economic considerations. light of geopolitical, historical, and economic considerations.
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

link to page 20 link to page 20 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Introduction
This report provides background information and analysis on the following topics: This report provides background information and analysis on the following topics:
 Domestic Turkish political and economic developments under President Recep  Domestic Turkish political and economic developments under President Recep
Tayyip Erdogan’s largely authoritarian and polarizing rule, including an ongoing Tayyip Erdogan’s largely authoritarian and polarizing rule, including an ongoing
currency crisis and its implications; currency crisis and its implications;
 Turkey’s strategic orientation—including toward the United States and Russia—  Turkey’s strategic orientation—including toward the United States and Russia—
as affected by Turkey’s S-400 surface-to-air defense system acquisition from as affected by Turkey’s S-400 surface-to-air defense system acquisition from
Russia and U.S. responses (including sanctions), Turkey’s greater use and export Russia and U.S. responses (including sanctions), Turkey’s greater use and export
of drone aircraft, the continuing U.S./NATO presence in Turkey, and regional of drone aircraft, the continuing U.S./NATO presence in Turkey, and regional
disputes and conflicts (such as those involving Syria, Greece, Cyprus, and disputes and conflicts (such as those involving Syria, Greece, Cyprus, and
Libya); and Libya); and
 various U.S. options regarding Turkey, including a possible sale and upgrade of  various U.S. options regarding Turkey, including a possible sale and upgrade of
F-16 aircraft, sanctions, military basing, and balancing U.S. ties with Turkey and F-16 aircraft, sanctions, military basing, and balancing U.S. ties with Turkey and
its regional rivals. its regional rivals.
For additional information, see CRS Report R41368, For additional information, see CRS Report R41368, Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations, by , by
Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas. Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas. See Figure A-1 for a map and key facts and figures about for a map and key facts and figures about
Turkey. Turkey.
Domestic Turkish Developments
Political Developments Under Erdogan’s Rule
President Erdogan has ruled Turkey since becoming prime minister in 2003 and, during that time, President Erdogan has ruled Turkey since becoming prime minister in 2003 and, during that time,
has deepened his control over the country’s populace and institutions. After Erdogan became has deepened his control over the country’s populace and institutions. After Erdogan became
president in August 2014 via Turkey’s first-ever popular presidential election, he claimed a president in August 2014 via Turkey’s first-ever popular presidential election, he claimed a
mandate for increasing his power and pursuing a “presidential system” of governance, which he mandate for increasing his power and pursuing a “presidential system” of governance, which he
cemented in a 2017 referendum and 2018 presidential and parliamentary elections. Some cemented in a 2017 referendum and 2018 presidential and parliamentary elections. Some
allegations of voter fraud and manipulation surfaced in both elections.1 Since a failed July 2016 allegations of voter fraud and manipulation surfaced in both elections.1 Since a failed July 2016
coup attempt, Erdogan and his Islamist-leaning Justice and Development Party (Turkish acronym coup attempt, Erdogan and his Islamist-leaning Justice and Development Party (Turkish acronym
AKP) have adopted more nationalistic domestic and foreign policy approaches, partly because of AKP) have adopted more nationalistic domestic and foreign policy approaches, partly because of
their reliance on parliamentary support from the Nationalist Movement Party (Turkish acronym their reliance on parliamentary support from the Nationalist Movement Party (Turkish acronym
MHP). As Turkey’s currency has struggled in recent years, leading to broader negative economic MHP). As Turkey’s currency has struggled in recent years, leading to broader negative economic
effects (discussed below), some observers write that deflecting domestic political attention from effects (discussed below), some observers write that deflecting domestic political attention from
economic difficulties has partly motivated a more assertive, nationalistic turn by Erdogan in economic difficulties has partly motivated a more assertive, nationalistic turn by Erdogan in
foreign policy.2 foreign policy.2
Many observers describe Erdogan as a polarizing figure,3 and elections have reflected roughly Many observers describe Erdogan as a polarizing figure,3 and elections have reflected roughly
equal portions of the country supporting and opposing his rule. The AKP maintained the largest equal portions of the country supporting and opposing his rule. The AKP maintained the largest

1 Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), Limited Referendum Observation Mission Final 1 Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), Limited Referendum Observation Mission Final
Report, Turkey, April 16, 2017 (published June 22, 2017); OSCE, International Election Observation Mission, Report, Turkey, April 16, 2017 (published June 22, 2017); OSCE, International Election Observation Mission,
Statement of Preliminary Findings and Conclusions, Turkey, Early Presidential and Parliamentary Elections, June 24, Statement of Preliminary Findings and Conclusions, Turkey, Early Presidential and Parliamentary Elections, June 24,
2018 (published June 25, 2018). 2018 (published June 25, 2018).
2 Yasmeen Serhan, “The End of the Secular Republic,” theatlantic.com, August 13, 2020. 2 Yasmeen Serhan, “The End of the Secular Republic,” theatlantic.com, August 13, 2020.
3 Seren Selvin Korkmaz, “Facing a changing main opposition, Erdogan doubles down on polarization,” Middle East 3 Seren Selvin Korkmaz, “Facing a changing main opposition, Erdogan doubles down on polarization,” Middle East
Institute, January 8, 2021. Institute, January 8, 2021.
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

1 1

link to page 6 link to page 6 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

share of votes in 2019 local elections, but lost some key municipalities, including Istanbul, to share of votes in 2019 local elections, but lost some key municipalities, including Istanbul, to
opposition candidates from the secular-leaning Republican People’s Party (Turkish acronym opposition candidates from the secular-leaning Republican People’s Party (Turkish acronym
CHP). The CHP and some other parties critical of Erdogan and the AKP have agreed on some CHP). The CHP and some other parties critical of Erdogan and the AKP have agreed on some
steps toward a broad opposition platform for the next national elections—scheduled to take place steps toward a broad opposition platform for the next national elections—scheduled to take place
by June 2023—focused on strengthening legislative and judicial checks on executive power. by June 2023—focused on strengthening legislative and judicial checks on executive power.
These opposition party leaders include Erdogan’s former high-ranking cabinet officials Ahmet These opposition party leaders include Erdogan’s former high-ranking cabinet officials Ahmet
Davutoglu and Ali Babacan, who one observer has said could help the opposition appeal more to Davutoglu and Ali Babacan, who one observer has said could help the opposition appeal more to
disgruntled Erdogan supporters.4 Additionally, some sources in late 2021 have questioned disgruntled Erdogan supporters.4 Additionally, some sources in late 2021 have questioned
Erdogan’s health.5 Erdogan’s health.5
U.S. and European Union (EU) officials have expressed a number of concerns about authoritarian U.S. and European Union (EU) officials have expressed a number of concerns about authoritarian
governance and erosion of rule of law and civil liberties in Turkey.6 In the government’s massive governance and erosion of rule of law and civil liberties in Turkey.6 In the government’s massive
response to the 2016 coup attempt, it detained tens of thousands, enacted sweeping changes to the response to the 2016 coup attempt, it detained tens of thousands, enacted sweeping changes to the
military and civilian agencies, and took over or closed various businesses, schools, and media military and civilian agencies, and took over or closed various businesses, schools, and media
outlets.7 In October 2021, President Erdogan threatened to expel 10 ambassadors from Western outlets.7 In October 2021, President Erdogan threatened to expel 10 ambassadors from Western
countries, including the United States, for a letter urging Turkey to abide by a European Court of countries, including the United States, for a letter urging Turkey to abide by a European Court of
Human Rights ruling calling for the release from prison of civil society figure Osman Kavala. Human Rights ruling calling for the release from prison of civil society figure Osman Kavala.
The crisis ended after the ambassadors publicly agreed to respect Turkey’s sovereignty.8 The crisis ended after the ambassadors publicly agreed to respect Turkey’s sovereignty.8
In 2021, the Erdogan government has pursued a Constitutional Court ruling to close down the In 2021, the Erdogan government has pursued a Constitutional Court ruling to close down the
Kurdish-oriented Peoples’ Democratic Party (Turkish acronym HDP), the third largest party in Kurdish-oriented Peoples’ Democratic Party (Turkish acronym HDP), the third largest party in
Turkey’s parliament. The government is seeking to ban the HDP on the basis of claims that it has Turkey’s parliament. The government is seeking to ban the HDP on the basis of claims that it has
ties to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (Kurdish acronym PKK, a U.S.-designated terrorist ties to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (Kurdish acronym PKK, a U.S.-designated terrorist
organization).9 In March 2021, the State Department said that banning the HDP “would unduly organization).9 In March 2021, the State Department said that banning the HDP “would unduly
subvert the will of Turkish voters, further undermine democracy in Turkey, and deny millions of subvert the will of Turkish voters, further undermine democracy in Turkey, and deny millions of
Turkish citizens their chosen representation.”10 How Kurds who feel politically marginalized Turkish citizens their chosen representation.”10 How Kurds who feel politically marginalized
might respond is unclear. Major violence between Turkish authorities and PKK militants—which might respond is unclear. Major violence between Turkish authorities and PKK militants—which
has taken place on and off since the 1980s—wracked Turkey’s mostly Kurdish southeast in 2015 has taken place on and off since the 1980s—wracked Turkey’s mostly Kurdish southeast in 2015
and 2016. and 2016.
Currency Crisis and Its Domestic Implications
Turkey is facing significant challenges as its currency, the Turkey is facing significant challenges as its currency, the lira, has depreciated in value , has depreciated in value ~~around~~
50more than 35% against the dollar in 2021.11 By reducing its key interest rate from 19% to 14% between % against the dollar in 2021.11 By reducing its key interest rate from 19% to 14% between
September and December, Turkey’s central bank may have accelerated rather than dampened September and December, Turkey’s central bank may have accelerated rather than dampened
annual inflation, which inflation, which ishas been officially estimated to be around officially estimated to be around 2030% and unofficially estimated as high as % and unofficially estimated as high as
58%.12 The lira has been trending downward for more than a decade, with the decline driven by 58%.12 The lira has been trending downward for more than a decade, with the decline driven by
broader concerns about Turkey’s rule of law and economy (seebroader concerns about Turkey’s rule of law and economy (see Figure 1). .

4 Carlotta Gall, “Turkish Opposition Joins Forces Against Erdogan,” 4 Carlotta Gall, “Turkish Opposition Joins Forces Against Erdogan,” New York Times, October 24, 2021. , October 24, 2021.
5 “Rumors swirl over Erdogan’s declining health after G20 hobble,” 5 “Rumors swirl over Erdogan’s declining health after G20 hobble,” Arab News, November 4, 2021. , November 4, 2021.
6 Department of State, “Turkey,” 6 Department of State, “Turkey,” Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2020; European Commission, ; European Commission, Turkey
2021 Report, October 19, 2021. , October 19, 2021.
7 Department of State, “Turkey”; European Commission, 7 Department of State, “Turkey”; European Commission, Turkey 2021 Report. .
8 Carlotta Gall, “Diplomacy Halts Erdogan’s Push to Expel Envoys,” 8 Carlotta Gall, “Diplomacy Halts Erdogan’s Push to Expel Envoys,” New York Times, October 26, 2021. , October 26, 2021.
9 Alex McDonald, “Threat to close pro-Kurdish party echoes long tradition in Turkey’s politics,” 9 Alex McDonald, “Threat to close pro-Kurdish party echoes long tradition in Turkey’s politics,” Middle East Eye, ,
March 20, 2021. March 20, 2021.
10 Department of State, “Actions in Turkey’s Parliament,” March 17, 2021. 10 Department of State, “Actions in Turkey’s Parliament,” March 17, 2021.
11 11 ~~Natasha Turak, “Turkish central bank cuts rates, sending lira to record low,” CNBC, December 16, 2021.~~
12“Turkish lira erodes last week’s gains,” Reuters, December 28, 2021. 12 Ibid.; Caitlin Ostroff, “Investors Fear Turkish Lira Has Further to Fall,” Caitlin Ostroff, “Investors Fear Turkish Lira Has Further to Fall,” Wall Street Journal, December 8, 2021. , December 8, 2021.
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

2 2

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Figure 1. Turkey: Currency Exchange Rate and Central Bank Interest Rate

Source: Reuters, November 2021. , November 2021.
Throughout this time, President Erdogan has assertively challenged the conventional economic Throughout this time, President Erdogan has assertively challenged the conventional economic
theory that raising interest rates stem inflation, attract foreign capital, and support the value of the theory that raising interest rates stem inflation, attract foreign capital, and support the value of the
currency. In replacing Turkey’s central bank governor and finance minister in 2021, Erdogan currency. In replacing Turkey’s central bank governor and finance minister in 2021, Erdogan
appears to have sought to bring Turkish fiscal and monetary policy more in line with his views. In appears to have sought to bring Turkish fiscal and monetary policy more in line with his views. In
public statements, Erdogan has argued that lower interest rates boost production, employment, public statements, Erdogan has argued that lower interest rates boost production, employment,
and exports.13 Erdogan also has criticized high interest rates as contrary to Islamic teachings and and exports.13 Erdogan also has criticized high interest rates as contrary to Islamic teachings and
as exacerbating the gap between rich and poor.14 as exacerbating the gap between rich and poor.14
Legacy of the 1999-2001 Financial Crisis15
The Turkish financial crisis of 1999-2001—amid domestic political instability fueled by a recession and 69% The Turkish financial crisis of 1999-2001—amid domestic political instability fueled by a recession and 69%
inflation at its outset—was a formative experience for President Erdogan and many other Turkish leaders of his inflation at its outset—was a formative experience for President Erdogan and many other Turkish leaders of his
generation. During the time of the crisis, Erdogan and his moderately Islamist political allies were forming a party generation. During the time of the crisis, Erdogan and his moderately Islamist political allies were forming a party
(the AKP, founded in 2001) to run competitively on the national stage. While the International Monetary Fund (the AKP, founded in 2001) to run competitively on the national stage. While the International Monetary Fund
(IMF)-assisted response to the 1999-2001 crisis arguably placed Turkey on a better long-term footing, especial y (IMF)-assisted response to the 1999-2001 crisis arguably placed Turkey on a better long-term footing, especial y
with the restructuring of its banking system, Erdogan’s stated unwil ingness in 2021 to accept IMF intervention in with the restructuring of its banking system, Erdogan’s stated unwil ingness in 2021 to accept IMF intervention in

13 “EXPLAINER: Turkey’s Currency Is Crashing. What’s the Impact?” 13 “EXPLAINER: Turkey’s Currency Is Crashing. What’s the Impact?” Associated Press, December 3, 2021; Carlotta , December 3, 2021; Carlotta
Gall, “Keeping His Own Counsel on Turkey’s Economy,” Gall, “Keeping His Own Counsel on Turkey’s Economy,” New York Times, December 11, 2021. , December 11, 2021.
14 Mustafa Akyol, “How Erdogan’s Pseudoscience Is Ruining the Turkish Economy,” Cato Institute, December 3, 14 Mustafa Akyol, “How Erdogan’s Pseudoscience Is Ruining the Turkish Economy,” Cato Institute, December 3,
2021; Gall, “Keeping His Own Counsel on Turkey2021; Gall, “Keeping His Own Counsel on Turkey'’s Economy.” s Economy.”
15 Sources used for this 15 Sources used for this ~~textbox~~text box include Calum Miller, “Pathways Through Financial Crisis: Turkey,” include Calum Miller, “Pathways Through Financial Crisis: Turkey,” Global
Governance, vol. 12, , vol. 12, o. no. 4, October-December 2006, pp. 449-464; Gokhan Capoglu, “Anatomy of a Failed IMF no. 4, October-December 2006, pp. 449-464; Gokhan Capoglu, “Anatomy of a Failed IMF
Program: The 1999 Program in Turkey,” Program: The 1999 Program in Turkey,” Emerging Markets Finance & Trade, vol. 40, no. 3, May-June 2004, pp. 84-, vol. 40, no. 3, May-June 2004, pp. 84-
100; Koen Brinke, “The Turkish 2000-01 banking crisis,” Rabobank, September 4, 2013, at 100; Koen Brinke, “The Turkish 2000-01 banking crisis,” Rabobank, September 4, 2013, at
https://economics.rabobank.com/publications/2013/september/the-turkish-2000-01-banking-crisis/; Emin https://economics.rabobank.com/publications/2013/september/the-turkish-2000-01-banking-crisis/; Emin
Avundukluoglu, “Turkey will never submit its economic future to IMF: President Erdogan,” Avundukluoglu, “Turkey will never submit its economic future to IMF: President Erdogan,” Anadolu Agency, ,
December 1, 2021; “Turkey pays off the last installment of its debt to IMF,” December 1, 2021; “Turkey pays off the last installment of its debt to IMF,” Anadolu Agency, May 14, 2013. , May 14, 2013.
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

3 3

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

resolving Turkey’s current crisis may stem in part from (1) serious volatility shocks (including extreme fluctuations resolving Turkey’s current crisis may stem in part from (1) serious volatility shocks (including extreme fluctuations
in interest rates and capital outflows) that occurred during the first 18 months of the Turkey-IMF program in in interest rates and capital outflows) that occurred during the first 18 months of the Turkey-IMF program in
1999-2001, (2) the years of oversight that Turkey faced while paying off IMF loans, and (3) the decisive November 1999-2001, (2) the years of oversight that Turkey faced while paying off IMF loans, and (3) the decisive November
2002 electoral defeat of the coalition government that presided over the crisis. 2002 electoral defeat of the coalition government that presided over the crisis.
In that election, Turkish voters did not give any of the coalition parties enough votes to stay in parliament, and the In that election, Turkish voters did not give any of the coalition parties enough votes to stay in parliament, and the
AKP won a majority of parliamentary seats. Despite its criticism during the 2002 campaign that involving the IMF AKP won a majority of parliamentary seats. Despite its criticism during the 2002 campaign that involving the IMF
compromised Turkey’s sovereignty, the AKP continued implementing Turkey’s standing agreements with the IMF compromised Turkey’s sovereignty, the AKP continued implementing Turkey’s standing agreements with the IMF
on economic reform, and the country benefitted from several years of strong economic growth—ful y paying off on economic reform, and the country benefitted from several years of strong economic growth—ful y paying off
its IMF debt (some of which dated back to 1961) in 2013. its IMF debt (some of which dated back to 1961) in 2013.
The The ~~ongoing~~ currency crisis has currency crisis has had several implications for Turkey and its people. The cost of living several implications for Turkey and its people. The cost of living
for consumers and for consumers and the cost of international borrowing for banks and private sector companiescost of international borrowing for banks and private sector companies ~~have~~
increased dramatically because Turkey relies heavily on imports for its population’s basic needs, increased dramatically because Turkey relies heavily on imports for its population’s basic needs,
including energy, and most foreign loans are denominated in dollars.16 A Turkish economistincluding energy, and most foreign loans are denominated in dollars.16 A Turkish economist ~~has~~
expressed concern over a possible “brain drain” of highly educated Turks, while also stating that expressed concern over a possible “brain drain” of highly educated Turks, while also stating that
despite lower interest rates, despite lower interest rates, ~~economic contraction may be likelier than growth~~the economy could contract rather than grow “as a result of the “as a result of the
panic and uncertainty and escalating costs coming from this crisis.”17 In December, Erdogan panic and uncertainty and escalating costs coming from this crisis.”17 In December, Erdogan
announced a 50% increase in Turkey’s minimum wage.18 Though presumably intended to bolster announced a 50% increase in Turkey’s minimum wage.18 Though presumably intended to bolster
Turks’ purchasing power given the weakened lira, higher wages could spark layoffs by Turks’ purchasing power given the weakened lira, higher wages could spark layoffs by
employers.19 employers.19
Turkish official sources Turkish official sources ~~have~~ presented some information presented some information ~~to support the current policy course. A~~
that could justify interest rate cuts. A central bank financial stability report from November 2021 stated that the Turkish banking sector central bank financial stability report from November 2021 stated that the Turkish banking sector
is sufficiently strong and has enough liquid assets to manage risks related to the lira’s value.20is sufficiently strong and has enough liquid assets to manage risks related to the lira’s value.20
Other sources Other sources ~~question~~questioned the resilience of Turkey’s financial system. the resilience of Turkey’s financial system. aA December 2021 December 2021 Wall Street
Journal article said, “A sudden surge in requests among Turkish residents to withdraw dollars article said, “A sudden surge in requests among Turkish residents to withdraw dollars
could force banks to draw down their foreign currency reserves or for the government to impose could force banks to draw down their foreign currency reserves or for the government to impose
capital controls that limit what people can remove.”21 According to one source, capital controls that limit what people can remove.”21 According to one source, as of mid-December almost 65% of almost 65% of
Turkish bank deposits Turkish bank deposits ~~are~~were in foreign currencies22—up from around 41% at the time of the 2016 in foreign currencies22—up from around 41% at the time of the 2016
coup attempt and 55% in January 2021.23 The central bank’s position became more precarious coup attempt and 55% in January 2021.23 The central bank’s position became more precarious
after its efforts in 2019 and 2020 to shore up the lira by selling a substantial amount of its foreign after its efforts in 2019 and 2020 to shore up the lira by selling a substantial amount of its foreign
exchange reserves.24 As of November 2021, one source stated that the bank’s foreign exchange exchange reserves.24 As of November 2021, one source stated that the bank’s foreign exchange
liabilities outweighed its assets by $15 billion when accounting for all transactions (including liabilities outweighed its assets by $15 billion when accounting for all transactions (including
~~currency swaps).25~~
currency swaps).25 On December 20, President Erdogan announced a government plan to broadly guarantee certain lira-denominated bank accounts against currency depreciation, in apparent coordination with a
16 “EXPLAINER: Turkey’s Currency Is Crashing. What’s the Impact?” 16 “EXPLAINER: Turkey’s Currency Is Crashing. What’s the Impact?” Associated Press. .
17 Ibid.; Ozge Ozdemir, “Why Turkey’s currency crash does not worry Erdogan,” 17 Ibid.; Ozge Ozdemir, “Why Turkey’s currency crash does not worry Erdogan,” BBC, December 3, 2021. , December 3, 2021.
18 Mustafa Sonmez, “Turkish lira sinks further with Erdogan’s latest rate cut,” 18 Mustafa Sonmez, “Turkish lira sinks further with Erdogan’s latest rate cut,” Al-Monitor, December 16, 2021. , December 16, 2021.
19 Nazlan Ertan, “Turkish lira tumbles ahead of key decision on rate cuts, wages,” 19 Nazlan Ertan, “Turkish lira tumbles ahead of key decision on rate cuts, wages,” Al-Monitor, December 14, 2021. , December 14, 2021.
20 Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey (20 Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey (Turkiye Cumhuriyet Merkez Bankasi), “Financial Stability Report,” ), “Financial Stability Report,”
November 2021, Volume 33. November 2021, Volume 33.
21 Ostroff, “Investors Fear Turkish Lira Has Further to Fall.” 21 Ostroff, “Investors Fear Turkish Lira Has Further to Fall.”
22 Sonmez, “Turkish lira sinks further with Erdogan’s latest rate cut.” 22 Sonmez, “Turkish lira sinks further with Erdogan’s latest rate cut.”
23 Capital Economics graphic, from Ostroff, “Investors Fear Turkish Lira Has Further to Fall.” 23 Capital Economics graphic, from Ostroff, “Investors Fear Turkish Lira Has Further to Fall.”
24 “‘Where is the $128B?’ Turkey’s opposition presses Erdogan,” 24 “‘Where is the $128B?’ Turkey’s opposition presses Erdogan,” Al Jazeera, April 14, 2021; Mustafa Sonmez, “Where , April 14, 2021; Mustafa Sonmez, “Where
is the money? Erdogan feels the heat over foreign reserves drain,” is the money? Erdogan feels the heat over foreign reserves drain,” Al-Monitor, February 24, 2021. , February 24, 2021.
25 “Turkey’s lira dives back into crisis territory,” 25 “Turkey’s lira dives back into crisis territory,” Reuters, November 18, 2021. , November 18, 2021.
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

4 4

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

~~There are also~~significant state-backed market intervention.26 In response, the lira gained back some of its earlier losses against the dollar, with some analysts expecting the practical results of the government’s action to largely simulate a hike in interest rates.27 It is unclear whether the government’s credit and domestic savers’ confidence will be sufficient to prevent future financial panic. The volatility of Turkey’s currency has implications for domestic politics. Public opinion polls suggest that support for implications for domestic politics. Public opinion polls suggest that support for
Erdogan and the AKP Erdogan and the AKP ishave been at historic lows, at historic lows,~~26 leading to speculation that~~28 feeding speculation about negative election outcomes for Erdogan and the current Erdogan and the current
AKP-MHP parliamentary AKP-MHP parliamentary ~~coalition might fall short of a majority or lose outright in future~~
~~elections.27~~coalition.29 Given youth unemployment estimates of 25%, Given youth unemployment estimates of 25%,2830 some observers some observers ~~speculate~~have speculated that the that the
economic concerns of millions of young voters could economic concerns of millions of young voters could ~~negatively~~ affect Erdogan’s prospects.affect Erdogan’s prospects.2931
Rivals from the CHP and other parties have called for early presidential and parliamentary Rivals from the CHP and other parties have called for early presidential and parliamentary
elections to allow for a change in leadership, but Erdogan controls whether to initiate elections elections to allow for a change in leadership, but Erdogan controls whether to initiate elections
before June 2023 and before June 2023 and ~~appears unwilling~~has thus far stated his unwillingness to do it. Rather than compel elections in Turkey, to do it. Rather than compel elections in Turkey,
domestic instability could lead Erdogan’s cabinet to initiate a state of emergency with the domestic instability could lead Erdogan’s cabinet to initiate a state of emergency with the
potential to delay elections.potential to delay elections.3032 Additionally, some observers debate whether (1) free and fair Additionally, some observers debate whether (1) free and fair
elections could take place under Erdogan,elections could take place under Erdogan,3133 (2) disgruntled Erdogan supporters would actually (2) disgruntled Erdogan supporters would actually
vote for opposition parties,vote for opposition parties,3234 or (3) Erdogan would cede power after an electoral defeat. or (3) Erdogan would cede power after an electoral defeat.33
35 Some analysts speculate that Erdogan’s December 2021 moves aimed at helping Turks gain back some of the purchasing power they lost in recent years could signal a plan to call elections for the near future.36 Turkey’s Strategic Orientation: Foreign Policy and
Military Involvement
General Assessment
Trends in Turkey’s relations with the United States and other countries reflect changes to Trends in Turkey’s relations with the United States and other countries reflect changes to
Turkey’s overall strategic orientation, as it has sought greater independence of action as a Turkey’s overall strategic orientation, as it has sought greater independence of action as a
regional power within a more multipolar global system. Turkey’s foreign policy course is regional power within a more multipolar global system. Turkey’s foreign policy course is
arguably less oriented to the West now than at any time since it joined NATO in 1952. Turkish arguably less oriented to the West now than at any time since it joined NATO in 1952. Turkish
~~leaders’ interest in reducing their dependence on the West for defense and discouraging Western~~
~~influence over their domestic politics may partly explain their willingness to coordinate some~~
~~actions with Russia in Syria and purchase a Russian S-400 surface-to-air defense system.~~
~~Nevertheless, Turkey retains significant differences with Russia—with which it has a long history~~
~~of discord—including over political outcomes in Syria, Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh (a region~~
~~disputed by Armenia and Azerbaijan).~~
~~In recent years, Turkey has involved its military in the Middle East, Eastern Mediterranean, and~~
~~Caucasus in a way that has affected its relationships with the United States and other key actors.~~
~~U.S. officials have sometimes encouraged cooperation among other allies and partners to counter~~

26 26 “Turkish lira erodes last week’s gains,” Reuters. 27 Amberin Zaman, “Lira rallies as Erdogan unveils new financial scheme, but jitters prevail,” Al-Monitor, December 21, 2021. 28 Jared Malsin, “Erdogan’s Support Sinks as Turkey’s Currency Collapses,” Jared Malsin, “Erdogan’s Support Sinks as Turkey’s Currency Collapses,” Wall Street Journal, December 14, 2021. , December 14, 2021.
2729 “Autumn of the patriarch,” “Autumn of the patriarch,” Economist, October 30, 2021. , October 30, 2021.
2830 Patricia Cohen, “Turkey Tries to Ward Off Meltdown of Economy,” Patricia Cohen, “Turkey Tries to Ward Off Meltdown of Economy,” New York Times, December 15, 2021. , December 15, 2021.
2931 Ozdemir, “Why Turkey’s currency crash does not worry Erdogan.” Ozdemir, “Why Turkey’s currency crash does not worry Erdogan.”
3032 “Professor says Turkey may declare state of emergency following economic crisis,” “Professor says Turkey may declare state of emergency following economic crisis,” Duvar English, December 14, , December 14,
2021; Carlotta Gall, “Frustration Rises as Turkey’s Lira Continues Plunge,” 2021; Carlotta Gall, “Frustration Rises as Turkey’s Lira Continues Plunge,” New York Times, December 2, 2021. , December 2, 2021.
3133 Simon A. Waldman, “Why Erdogan Will Survive Turkey’s Horrifying Crash,” haaretz.com, December 17, 2021; Simon A. Waldman, “Why Erdogan Will Survive Turkey’s Horrifying Crash,” haaretz.com, December 17, 2021;
Kemal Kirisci and Berk Esen, “Might the Turkish Electorate Be Ready to Say Goodbye to Erdoğan After Two Decades Kemal Kirisci and Berk Esen, “Might the Turkish Electorate Be Ready to Say Goodbye to Erdoğan After Two Decades
in Power?” in Power?” Just Security, November 22, 2021. , November 22, 2021.
3234 Ozer Sencar of Metropoll, in Laura Pitel, “Will the ailing Turkish economy bring Erdogan down?” Ozer Sencar of Metropoll, in Laura Pitel, “Will the ailing Turkish economy bring Erdogan down?” Financial Times, ,
November 1, 2021. November 1, 2021.
3335 Pitel, “Will the ailing Turkish economy bring Erdogan down?”; Kirisci and Esen, “Might the Turkish Electorate Be Pitel, “Will the ailing Turkish economy bring Erdogan down?”; Kirisci and Esen, “Might the Turkish Electorate Be
Ready to Say Goodbye to Erdoğan After Two Decades in Power?” Ready to Say Goodbye to Erdoğan After Two Decades in Power?”
~~Congressional Research Service~~

5

~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

36 “Erdogan Looking to Cash in on Economy Gains With Early Election, Analysts Say,” Reuters, December 29, 2021. Congressional Research Service 5 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief leaders’ interest in reducing their dependence on the West for defense and discouraging Western influence over their domestic politics may partly explain their willingness to coordinate some actions with Russia in Syria and purchase a Russian S-400 surface-to-air defense system. Nevertheless, Turkey retains significant differences with Russia—with which it has a long history of discord—including over political outcomes in Syria, Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh (a region disputed by Armenia and Azerbaijan). In recent years, Turkey has involved its military in the Middle East, Eastern Mediterranean, and Caucasus in a way that has affected its relationships with the United States and other key actors. U.S. officials have sometimes encouraged cooperation among other allies and partners to counter Turkish actions. Nevertheless, U.S. and Turkish officials maintain that bilateral cooperation on Turkish actions. Nevertheless, U.S. and Turkish officials maintain that bilateral cooperation on
regional security matters remains mutually important.regional security matters remains mutually important.3437
Turkish leaders appear to compartmentalize their partnerships and rivalries with other influential Turkish leaders appear to compartmentalize their partnerships and rivalries with other influential
countries as each situation dictates, partly in an attempt to reduce Turkey’s dependence on these countries as each situation dictates, partly in an attempt to reduce Turkey’s dependence on these
actors and maintain its leverage with them.actors and maintain its leverage with them.3538 Traditionally, Turkey has relied closely on the Traditionally, Turkey has relied closely on the
United States and NATO for defense cooperation, European countries for trade and investment United States and NATO for defense cooperation, European countries for trade and investment
(including a customs union with the EU since the late 1990s), and Russia and Iran for energy (including a customs union with the EU since the late 1990s), and Russia and Iran for energy
imports. Without a means of global power projection or major natural resource wealth, Turkey’s imports. Without a means of global power projection or major natural resource wealth, Turkey’s
military strength and economic well-being appear to remain largely dependent on these traditional military strength and economic well-being appear to remain largely dependent on these traditional
relationships. Turkey’s ongoing economic struggles (discussed above) highlight the risks it faces relationships. Turkey’s ongoing economic struggles (discussed above) highlight the risks it faces
in jeopardizing these ties.in jeopardizing these ties.3639
Turkey’s compartmentalized approach may to some extent reflect President Erdogan’s efforts to Turkey’s compartmentalized approach may to some extent reflect President Erdogan’s efforts to
consolidate control domestically. Because Erdogan’s Islamist-friendly AKP maintains a consolidate control domestically. Because Erdogan’s Islamist-friendly AKP maintains a
parliamentary majority in partnership with the more traditionally nationalist MHP, efforts to parliamentary majority in partnership with the more traditionally nationalist MHP, efforts to
maintain the support of core constituencies may imbue Turkish policy with a nationalistic tenor. A maintain the support of core constituencies may imbue Turkish policy with a nationalistic tenor. A
largely nationalistic foreign policy also has precedent from before Turkey’s Cold War alignment largely nationalistic foreign policy also has precedent from before Turkey’s Cold War alignment
with the West.with the West.3740 Turkey’s history as both a regional power and an object of great power Turkey’s history as both a regional power and an object of great power
aggression contributes to wide domestic popularity for nationalistic political actions and aggression contributes to wide domestic popularity for nationalistic political actions and
discourse, as well as sympathy for Erdogan’s “neo-Ottoman” narrative of restoring Turkish discourse, as well as sympathy for Erdogan’s “neo-Ottoman” narrative of restoring Turkish
regional prestige. regional prestige.
~~Turkish Hard Power: Using Drones and Proxy Forces in Regional Conflicts~~
~~During Erdogan’s first decade as prime minister (2003-2012), Turkey’s main approach in its surrounding region~~
~~(with the exception of its long-running security operations against the PKK in southeastern Turkey and northern~~
~~Iraq) was to project political and economic influence, or “soft power,” backed by diplomacy and military~~
~~deterrence. As regional unrest increased near Turkey’s borders with the onset of conflict in Syria, however,~~
~~Turkey’s approach shifted dramatically in light of newly perceived threats. This was especially the case after~~
~~Erdogan (elected president in 2014) began courting Turkish nationalist constituencies in 2015 and consolidating~~
~~power fol owing the July 2016 coup attempt.~~
~~Under this modified approach, Turkey now relies more on hard power to affect regional outcomes. Specifically,~~
~~Turkey has focused on a relatively low-cost method of using armed drone aircraft and/or proxy forces~~
~~(particularly Syrian fighters who oppose the Syrian government and otherwise have limited sources of income) in~~
~~theaters of conflict including northern Syria and Iraq, western Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh.38 Partly because the~~
~~drones and proxy forces limit Turkey’s political and economic risk, Turkish leaders have shown less constraint in~~
~~deploying them, and they have reportedly proven effective at countering other actors’ more expensive but less~~
~~mobile armored vehicles and air defense systems (such as with Russian-assisted forces in Syria, Libya, and~~
~~Nagorno-Karabakh).39~~

34Turkey’s strategic orientation is a major consideration for the United States. The Biden Administration arguably signaled a more distant approach to Erdogan than President Trump’s with President Biden’s April 2021 statement recognizing as genocide actions by the Ottoman Empire (Turkey’s predecessor state) against Armenians during World War I.41 The Biden Administration also has been more outspoken on what it sees as threats to democracy, rule of law, and human rights in Turkey. However, the Administration, along with the EU, has praised Turkey’s approach to hosting refugees.42 Of the refugees currently residing in Turkey, according 37 “Biden, Erdogan upbeat about ties but disclose no breakthrough,” “Biden, Erdogan upbeat about ties but disclose no breakthrough,” Reuters, June 14, 2021; State Department, “U.S. , June 14, 2021; State Department, “U.S.
Relations with Turkey: Bilateral Relations Fact Sheet,” January 20, 2021. Relations with Turkey: Bilateral Relations Fact Sheet,” January 20, 2021.
3538 Stephen J. Flanagan et al., Stephen J. Flanagan et al., Turkey’s Nationalist Course: Implications for the U.S.-Turkish Strategic Partnership and
the U.S. Army, RAND Corporation, 2020. , RAND Corporation, 2020.
3639 Diego Cupolo, “Turkish lira nears record lows as emerging markets struggle,” Diego Cupolo, “Turkish lira nears record lows as emerging markets struggle,” Al-Monitor, May 13, 2021. , May 13, 2021.
3740 Marc Pierini, “How Far Can Turkey Challenge NATO and the EU in 2020?” Marc Pierini, “How Far Can Turkey Challenge NATO and the EU in 2020?” Carnegie Europe, January 29, 2020. , January 29, 2020.
~~38 See, e.g., Rich Outzen, Deals, Drones, and National Will: The New Era in Turkish Power Projection, Washington~~
~~Institute for Near East Policy, July 2021.~~
~~39 James Marson and Brett Forrest, “Low-Cost Armed Drones Reshape War and Geopolitics,” Wall Street Journal,~~
~~June 4, 2021; Mitch Prothero, “Turkey’s Erdogan has been humiliating Putin all year—here’s how he did it,”~~ ~~Business~~
~~Insider, October 22, 2020~~41 White House, “Statement by President Joe Biden on Armenian Remembrance Day,” April 24, 2021. 42 United States Mission to the United Nations, “Remarks by Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield during a Press Briefing at the Conclusion of Travel to Turkey,” June 4, 2021; Nazlan Ertan, “Amid Afghan influx, Turkey’s refugee policy gets tested with fire,” Al-Monitor, July 28, 2021. .
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

6 6

link to page 16 link to page 16 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

~~How these efforts might influence political outcomes remains unclear (see~~ ~~“Regional Conflicts and Disputes”~~
~~below for discussions of Syria and Libya). In December 2021, Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu~~
~~announced Turkey’s intention to move toward normalizing its relations with Armenia, a course of action~~
~~reportedly suggested by President Biden to President Erdogan.40~~
~~Turkey’s strategic orientation is a major consideration for the United States. The Biden~~
~~Administration arguably signaled a more distant approach to Erdogan than President Trump’s~~
~~with President Biden’s April 2021 statement recognizing as genocide actions by the Ottoman~~
~~Empire (Turkey’s predecessor state) against Armenians during World War I.41 The Biden~~
~~Administration also has been more outspoken on what it sees as threats to democracy, rule of law,~~
~~and human rights in Turkey. However, the Administration, along with the EU, has praised~~
~~Turkey’s approach to hosting refugees.42 Of the refugees currently residing in Turkey, according~~
~~to the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) approximately 3.6 million refugees have~~
~~come from Syria, and about 320,000 persons of concern from other countries (including~~
~~Afghanistan).43~~
~~Russian S-400 Acquisition:~~
to the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) approximately 3.6 million refugees have come from Syria, and about 320,000 persons of concern from other countries (including Afghanistan).43 Turkish Hard Power: Using Drones and Proxy Forces in Regional Conflicts During Erdogan’s first decade as prime minister (2003-2012), Turkey’s main approach in its surrounding region (with the exception of its long-running security operations against the PKK in southeastern Turkey and northern Iraq) was to project political and economic influence, or “soft power,” backed by diplomacy and military deterrence. As regional unrest increased near Turkey’s borders with the onset of conflict in Syria, however, Turkey’s approach shifted dramatically in light of newly perceived threats. This was especial y the case after Erdogan (elected president in 2014) began courting Turkish nationalist constituencies in 2015 and consolidating power fol owing the July 2016 coup attempt. Under this modified approach, Turkey now relies more on hard power to affect regional outcomes. Specifically, Turkey has focused on a relatively low-cost method of using armed drone aircraft and/or proxy forces (particularly Syrian fighters who oppose the Syrian government and otherwise have limited sources of income) in theaters of conflict including northern Syria and Iraq, western Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh.44 Partly because the drones and proxy forces limit Turkey’s political and economic risk, Turkish leaders have shown less constraint in deploying them, and they have reportedly proven effective at countering other actors’ more expensive but less mobile armored vehicles and air defense systems (such as with Russian-assisted forces in Syria, Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh).45 How these efforts might influence political outcomes remains unclear (see “Regional Conflicts and Disputes” below for discussions of Syria and Libya). In December 2021, Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu announced Turkey’s intention to move toward normalizing its relations with Armenia, a course of action reportedly suggested by President Biden to President Erdogan.46 Russian S-400 Acquisition: Removal from F-35 Program, U.S. Sanctions, and F-16 Request
Background
Turkey’s acquisition of a Russian S-400 surface-to-air defense system, which Turkey ordered in Turkey’s acquisition of a Russian S-400 surface-to-air defense system, which Turkey ordered in
2017 and Russia delivered in 2019,2017 and Russia delivered in 2019,4447 has significant implications for Turkey’s relations with has significant implications for Turkey’s relations with
Russia, the United States, and other NATO countries. As a direct result of the transaction, the Russia, the United States, and other NATO countries. As a direct result of the transaction, the
Trump Administration removed Turkey from the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter program in July 2019, Trump Administration removed Turkey from the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter program in July 2019,
and imposed sanctions under the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act and imposed sanctions under the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act
(CAATSA, P.L. 115-44) on Turkey’s defense procurement agency in December 2020.(CAATSA, P.L. 115-44) on Turkey’s defense procurement agency in December 2020.~~45 In~~
~~explaining the U.S. decision to remove Turkey from the F-35 program, then-Under Secretary of~~
~~Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment Ellen Lord said, “Turkey cannot field a Russian~~
~~intelligence collection platform [within the S-400 system] in proximity to where the F-35~~
~~program makes, repairs and houses the F-35. Much of the F-35’s strength lies in its stealth~~
~~capabilities, so the ability to detect those capabilities would jeopardize the long-term security of~~
~~the F-35 program.”46~~

~~40 Selcan Hacaoglu, “Turkey Moves to Normalize Armenia Ties in Bid to Please Biden,” Bloomberg, December 13,~~
~~2021. For more on Turkey-Armenia relations, see CRS Report R41368, Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations, by~~
~~Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas.~~
~~41 White House, “Statement by President Joe Biden on Armenian Remembrance Day,” April 24, 2021.~~
~~42 United States Mission to the United Nations, “Remarks by Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield during a Press~~
~~Briefing at the Conclusion of Travel to Turkey,” June 4, 2021; Nazlan Ertan, “Amid Afghan influx, Turkey’s refugee~~
~~policy gets tested with fire,” Al-Monitor, July 28, 2021.~~
~~43 UNHCR, “Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Turkey,” https://www.unhcr.org/tr/en/refugees-and-asylum-seekers-in-~~
~~turkey.~~
4448 In 43 UNHCR, “Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Turkey,” https://www.unhcr.org/tr/en/refugees-and-asylum-seekers-in-turkey. 44 See, e.g., Rich Outzen, Deals, Drones, and National Will: The New Era in Turkish Power Projection, Washington Institute for Near East Policy, July 2021. 45 James Marson and Brett Forrest, “Low-Cost Armed Drones Reshape War and Geopolitics,” Wall Street Journal, June 4, 2021; Mitch Prothero, “Turkey’s Erdogan has been humiliating Putin all year—here’s how he did it,” Business Insider, October 22, 2020. 46 Selcan Hacaoglu, “Turkey Moves to Normalize Armenia Ties in Bid to Please Biden,” Bloomberg, December 13, 2021. For more on Turkey-Armenia relations, see CRS Report R41368, Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations, by Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas. 47 “Turkey, Russia sign deal on supply of S-400 missiles,” “Turkey, Russia sign deal on supply of S-400 missiles,” Reuters, December 29, 2017. According to this source, December 29, 2017. According to this source,
Turkey and Russia reached agreement on the sale of at least one S-400 system for $2.5 billion, with the possibility of a Turkey and Russia reached agreement on the sale of at least one S-400 system for $2.5 billion, with the possibility of a
second system to come later. second system to come later.
4548 CRS Insight IN11557, CRS Insight IN11557, Turkey: U.S. Sanctions Under the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act
~~(CAATSA), by Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas.~~
~~46 Department of Defense transcript,~~ Congressional Research Service 7 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief explaining the U.S. decision to remove Turkey from the F-35 program, then-Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment Ellen Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment Ellen ~~M. Lord and~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

7

~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~
Lord said, “Turkey cannot field a Russian intelligence collection platform [within the S-400 system] in proximity to where the F-35 program makes, repairs and houses the F-35. Much of the F-35’s strength lies in its stealth capabilities, so the ability to detect those capabilities would jeopardize the long-term security of the F-35 program.”49
Turkish interest in procurement deals that feature technology sharing and co-production—thereby Turkish interest in procurement deals that feature technology sharing and co-production—thereby
bolstering Turkey’s domestic defense industry—may have affected its S-400 decision. bolstering Turkey’s domestic defense industry—may have affected its S-400 decision.
Strengthening its defense industry became a priority for Turkey after the 1975-1978 U.S. arms Strengthening its defense industry became a priority for Turkey after the 1975-1978 U.S. arms
embargo over Cyprus.embargo over Cyprus.4750 Over time, Turkish companies have supplied an increased percentage of Over time, Turkish companies have supplied an increased percentage of
Turkey’s defense needs, with equipment ranging from armored personnel carriers and naval Turkey’s defense needs, with equipment ranging from armored personnel carriers and naval
vessels to drone aircraft. While Turkey’s S-400 purchase reportedly does not feature technology vessels to drone aircraft. While Turkey’s S-400 purchase reportedly does not feature technology
sharing,sharing,4851 Turkish officials have expressed hope that a future deal with Russia involving Turkish officials have expressed hope that a future deal with Russia involving
technology sharing and co-production might be possible to address Turkey’s longer-term air technology sharing and co-production might be possible to address Turkey’s longer-term air
defense needs, with another potential option being Turkish co-development of a system with defense needs, with another potential option being Turkish co-development of a system with
European partners.European partners.4952 Lack of agreement between the United States and Turkey on technology Lack of agreement between the United States and Turkey on technology
sharing regarding the Patriot system possibly contributed to Turkey’s interest in considering non-sharing regarding the Patriot system possibly contributed to Turkey’s interest in considering non-
U.S. options for air defense, including an abortive attempt from 2013 to 2015 to purchase a U.S. options for air defense, including an abortive attempt from 2013 to 2015 to purchase a
Chinese system.Chinese system.5053
Other factors may have influenced Turkey’s decision to purchase the S-400 instead of the Patriot. Other factors may have influenced Turkey’s decision to purchase the S-400 instead of the Patriot.
One is Turkey’s apparent desire to diversify its foreign arms sources.One is Turkey’s apparent desire to diversify its foreign arms sources.5154 Another is Turkish Another is Turkish
President Erdogan’s possible interest in defending against U.S.-origin aircraft such as those used President Erdogan’s possible interest in defending against U.S.-origin aircraft such as those used
by some Turkish military personnel in the 2016 coup attempt.by some Turkish military personnel in the 2016 coup attempt.5255
Turkey has conducted some testing of the S-400 but has not made the system generally Turkey has conducted some testing of the S-400 but has not made the system generally
operational. President Erdogan stated in September 2021 that Turkey expects to purchase a operational. President Erdogan stated in September 2021 that Turkey expects to purchase a
second S-400 system.second S-400 system.5356 Secretary of State Antony Blinken has warned Turkey that acquiring an Secretary of State Antony Blinken has warned Turkey that acquiring an
additional system could lead to more U.S. sanctions under CAATSA.additional system could lead to more U.S. sanctions under CAATSA.5457 Turkey may need to forgo Turkey may need to forgo
possession or use of the S-400 in order to have CAATSA sanctions removed. possession or use of the S-400 in order to have CAATSA sanctions removed.
In the fall of 2021, Turkish officials stated that they had requested to purchase 40 new F-16 In the fall of 2021, Turkish officials stated that they had requested to purchase 40 new F-16
fighter aircraft from the United States and to upgrade 80 F-16s from Turkey’s aging fleet. fighter aircraft from the United States and to upgrade 80 F-16s from Turkey’s aging fleet.
~~President Erdogan has called for the Biden Administration to apply $1.4 billion that Turkey paid~~
~~toward F-35s to the approximate $6 billion cost for the F-16 package.55 President Biden~~
~~reportedly discussed the F-16 request with Erdogan during an October 2021 G20 meeting in~~
~~Rome, indicating that the request would go through the regular arms sales consultation and~~
~~notification process with Congress.56~~

(CAATSA), by Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas. 49 Department of Defense transcript, Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment Ellen M. Lord and Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy David J. Trachtenberg Press Briefing on DOD’s Response to Turkey Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy David J. Trachtenberg Press Briefing on DOD’s Response to Turkey
Accepting Delivery of the Russian S-400 Air and Missile Defense System, July 17, 2019. Accepting Delivery of the Russian S-400 Air and Missile Defense System, July 17, 2019.
4750 Omar Lamrani, “Facing Sanctions, Turkey’s Defense Industry Goes to Plan B,” Omar Lamrani, “Facing Sanctions, Turkey’s Defense Industry Goes to Plan B,” Stratfor, November 7, 2019. , November 7, 2019.
4851 Aaron Stein, “Putin’s Victory: Why Turkey and America Made Each Other Weaker,” Foreign Policy Research Aaron Stein, “Putin’s Victory: Why Turkey and America Made Each Other Weaker,” Foreign Policy Research
Institute, July 29, 2019. Institute, July 29, 2019.
4952 Burak Ege Bekdil, “West’s reluctance to share tech pushes Turkey further into Russian orbit,” Burak Ege Bekdil, “West’s reluctance to share tech pushes Turkey further into Russian orbit,” Defense News, ,
January 10, 2020. January 10, 2020.
5053 Flanagan et al., Flanagan et al., Turkey’s Nationalist Course. .
5154 “Turkey is buying Russian missiles to diversify supply,” “Turkey is buying Russian missiles to diversify supply,” Oxford Analytica, January 26, 2018. , January 26, 2018.
5255 Nicholas Danforth, “Frustration, Fear, and the Fate of U.S.-Turkish Relations,” German Marshall Fund of the United Nicholas Danforth, “Frustration, Fear, and the Fate of U.S.-Turkish Relations,” German Marshall Fund of the United
States, July 19, 2019; Ali Demirdas, “S-400 and More: Why Does Turkey Want Russian Military Technology So States, July 19, 2019; Ali Demirdas, “S-400 and More: Why Does Turkey Want Russian Military Technology So
Badly?” nationalinterest.org, July 14, 2019. Badly?” nationalinterest.org, July 14, 2019.
5356 Humeyra Pamuk, “Erdogan says Turkey plans to buy more Russian defense systems,” Humeyra Pamuk, “Erdogan says Turkey plans to buy more Russian defense systems,” Reuters, September 27, 2021. , September 27, 2021.
5457 Tal Axelrod, “Blinken warns Turkey, US allies against purchasing Russian weapons,” Tal Axelrod, “Blinken warns Turkey, US allies against purchasing Russian weapons,” The Hill, April 28, 2021. , April 28, 2021.
~~55 Abraham Mahshie, “Turkey’s Erdogan and Biden to Face Off over F-16 and F-35 Debacle,” Air Force Magazine,~~
~~October 29, 2021.~~
~~56 “Biden talks F-16s, raises human rights in meeting with Turkey’s Erdogan,” Reuters, October 31, 2021; Diego~~
~~Cupolo, “In troubled US-Turkey relations, F-16 deal seen as path for dialogue,” Al-Monitor, November 1, 2021. For~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

8

~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

Congressional Research Service 8 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief President Erdogan has called for the Biden Administration to apply $1.4 billion that Turkey paid toward F-35s to the approximate $6 billion cost for the F-16 package.58 President Biden reportedly discussed the F-16 request with Erdogan during an October 2021 G20 meeting in Rome, indicating that the request would go through the regular arms sales consultation and notification process with Congress.59 U.S. Policy Implications
How Turkey procures key weapons systems is relevant to U.S. policy in part because it affects How Turkey procures key weapons systems is relevant to U.S. policy in part because it affects
Turkey’s partnerships with major powers. For decades, Turkey has relied on certain U.S.-origin Turkey’s partnerships with major powers. For decades, Turkey has relied on certain U.S.-origin
equipment such as aircraft, helicopters, missiles, and other munitions to maintain military equipment such as aircraft, helicopters, missiles, and other munitions to maintain military
strength.strength.5760 Turkey’s purchase of the S-400 and its exploration of possibly acquiring Russian Turkey’s purchase of the S-400 and its exploration of possibly acquiring Russian
fighter aircraft (as discussed below) may raise the question: If Turkey transitions to major Russian fighter aircraft (as discussed below) may raise the question: If Turkey transitions to major Russian
weapons platforms with multi-decade lifespans, how can it stay closely integrated with the United weapons platforms with multi-decade lifespans, how can it stay closely integrated with the United
States and NATO on defense matters? States and NATO on defense matters?
Before Turkey’s July 2019 removal from the F-35 program, it had planned to purchase at least Before Turkey’s July 2019 removal from the F-35 program, it had planned to purchase at least
100 U.S.-origin F-35s and was one of eight original consortium partners in the development and 100 U.S.-origin F-35s and was one of eight original consortium partners in the development and
industrial production of the aircraft.industrial production of the aircraft.5861 Section 1245 of the FY2020 National Defense Section 1245 of the FY2020 National Defense
Authorization Act (P.L. 116-92) prohibits the use of U.S. funds to transfer F-35s to Turkey unless Authorization Act (P.L. 116-92) prohibits the use of U.S. funds to transfer F-35s to Turkey unless
the Secretaries of Defense and State certify that Turkey no longer possesses the S-400. the Secretaries of Defense and State certify that Turkey no longer possesses the S-400.
An August 2020 An August 2020 Defense News article reported that some Members of Congress had “blocked” article reported that some Members of Congress had “blocked”
major new U.S.-origin arms sales to Turkey in connection with the S-400 transaction. Such a major new U.S.-origin arms sales to Turkey in connection with the S-400 transaction. Such a
disruption to U.S.-Turkey arms sales has not occurred since the 1975-1978 embargo over disruption to U.S.-Turkey arms sales has not occurred since the 1975-1978 embargo over
Cyprus.Cyprus.5962 Major sales (valued at $25 million or more) Major sales (valued at $25 million or more) on hold, according to the article, included on hold, according to the article, included
F-16 upgrades and export licenses for engines involved in a Turkish sale of attack helicopters to F-16 upgrades and export licenses for engines involved in a Turkish sale of attack helicopters to
Pakistan. Sales already underway or for smaller items and services—such as spare parts, Pakistan. Sales already underway or for smaller items and services—such as spare parts,
ammunition, and maintenance packages for older equipment—were not subject to these reported ammunition, and maintenance packages for older equipment—were not subject to these reported
holds. holds.
Biden Administration discussions with Turkey have sought to end the countries’ impasse over the Biden Administration discussions with Turkey have sought to end the countries’ impasse over the
S-400, in hopes of halting CAATSA sanctions and bringing U.S.-Turkey defense cooperation S-400, in hopes of halting CAATSA sanctions and bringing U.S.-Turkey defense cooperation
closer to past levels. President Erdogan reiterated his unwillingness to give up the S-400 in a June closer to past levels. President Erdogan reiterated his unwillingness to give up the S-400 in a June
2021 meeting with President Biden.2021 meeting with President Biden.60
~~Turkey’s request to purchase new F-16s and upgrade others faces some opposition in Congress,~~
~~partly based on the S-400 issue.61 At a September 28, 2021, Senate Foreign Relations Committee~~
~~hearing, Chairman Bob Menendez said, “I see no arms sales going to Turkey, unless there is a~~
~~dramatic change around on the S-400.”62 If Turkey cannot partner with the United States to~~

63 58 Abraham Mahshie, “Turkey’s Erdogan and Biden to Face Off over F-16 and F-35 Debacle,” Air Force Magazine, October 29, 2021. 59 “Biden talks F-16s, raises human rights in meeting with Turkey’s Erdogan,” Reuters, October 31, 2021; Diego Cupolo, “In troubled US-Turkey relations, F-16 deal seen as path for dialogue,” Al-Monitor, November 1, 2021. For background information, see CRS Report RL31675, background information, see CRS Report RL31675, Arms Sales: Congressional Review Process, by Paul K. Kerr. , by Paul K. Kerr.
5760 Turkey also has procurement and co-development relationships with other NATO allies, including Germany Turkey also has procurement and co-development relationships with other NATO allies, including Germany
(submarines), Italy (helicopters and reconnaissance satellites), and the United Kingdom (a fighter aircraft prototype). (submarines), Italy (helicopters and reconnaissance satellites), and the United Kingdom (a fighter aircraft prototype).
5861 A 2007 memorandum of understanding among the consortium participants is available at https://www.state.gov/ A 2007 memorandum of understanding among the consortium participants is available at https://www.state.gov/
documents/organization/102378.pdf, and an earlier 2002 U.S.-Turkey agreement is available at https://www.state.gov/documents/organization/102378.pdf, and an earlier 2002 U.S.-Turkey agreement is available at https://www.state.gov/
documents/organization/196467.pdf. For information on the consortium and its members, see CRS Report RL30563, documents/organization/196467.pdf. For information on the consortium and its members, see CRS Report RL30563, F-
35 Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) Program, by Jeremiah Gertler. , by Jeremiah Gertler.
5962 Valerie Insinna et al., “Congress has secretly blocked US arms sales to Turkey for nearly two years,” Valerie Insinna et al., “Congress has secretly blocked US arms sales to Turkey for nearly two years,” Defense News, ,
August 12, 2020. August 12, 2020.
6063 “Erdogan says he told Biden Turkey is not shifting on S-400s—state media,” “Erdogan says he told Biden Turkey is not shifting on S-400s—state media,” Reuters, June 17, 2021. , June 17, 2021.
~~61 The text of a letter from 42 Representatives to Secretary Blinken opposing the F-16 transaction is available at~~
~~https://pappas.house.gov/media/press-releases/pappas-leads-colleagues-opposing-sale-f-16s-turkey-demands-~~
~~information-state.~~
~~62 Congressional Quarterly Congressional Transcripts (requires paid subscription), available at~~
~~http://www.cq.com/doc/congressionaltranscripts-6353520?5&search=s5LStXmK.~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

9

~~link to page 21~~ ~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

Congressional Research Service 9 link to page 21 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief Turkey’s request to purchase new F-16s and upgrade others faces some opposition in Congress, partly based on the S-400 issue.64 At a September 28, 2021, Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing, Chairman Bob Menendez said, “I see no arms sales going to Turkey, unless there is a dramatic change around on the S-400.”65 If Turkey cannot partner with the United States to modernize its fighter aircraft, it could turn to Russia or other alternative suppliers.modernize its fighter aircraft, it could turn to Russia or other alternative suppliers.6366 Turkish Turkish
officials have expressed openness to acquiring Russia’s Su-35 aircraft.officials have expressed openness to acquiring Russia’s Su-35 aircraft.6467
Drones: Domestic Production, U.S. and Western Components,
and Exports
Over the past decade, Turkey has built up a formidable arsenal of unmanned aerial vehicles Over the past decade, Turkey has built up a formidable arsenal of unmanned aerial vehicles
(UAVs), or drone aircraft, to carry out armed attacks or perform target acquisition. Their primary (UAVs), or drone aircraft, to carry out armed attacks or perform target acquisition. Their primary
purpose has been to counter the PKK or PKK-linked militias in southeastern Turkey, Iraq, and purpose has been to counter the PKK or PKK-linked militias in southeastern Turkey, Iraq, and
Syria. Turkey and its allies also have reportedly used armed drones against other actors in Syria, Syria. Turkey and its allies also have reportedly used armed drones against other actors in Syria,
Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh (see Libya, and Nagorno-Karabakh (see ~~textbox~~text box above). Open source accounts have reported that the above). Open source accounts have reported that the
drones have been effective in targeting adversaries, while also raising concerns about the legality drones have been effective in targeting adversaries, while also raising concerns about the legality
of their use in these settings and the danger they pose to civilians.of their use in these settings and the danger they pose to civilians.6568
Turkey has focused on producing drones domestically. This is partly due to its failure in the early Turkey has focused on producing drones domestically. This is partly due to its failure in the early
2010s to acquire U.S.-made armed MQ-9 Reapers—reportedly because of congressional 2010s to acquire U.S.-made armed MQ-9 Reapers—reportedly because of congressional
~~opposition66~~opposition69—and partly due to reported concerns that Israel may have deliberately delivered —and partly due to reported concerns that Israel may have deliberately delivered
underperforming versions of its Heron reconnaissance drones to Turkey in 2010.underperforming versions of its Heron reconnaissance drones to Turkey in 2010.6770 Kale Group Kale Group
and Baykar Technologies have produced the Bayraktar TB2 (seand Baykar Technologies have produced the Bayraktar TB2 (see Figure A-2), and Turkish , and Turkish
Aerospace Industries (TAI) has produced the Anka-S. Turkey anticipates adding both larger and Aerospace Industries (TAI) has produced the Anka-S. Turkey anticipates adding both larger and
smaller drones to its arsenal over the next decade.smaller drones to its arsenal over the next decade.6871 Selcuk Bayraktar, a son-in-law of President Selcuk Bayraktar, a son-in-law of President
Erdogan, has played a key role in engineering the Bayraktar drones that dominate Turkey’s Erdogan, has played a key role in engineering the Bayraktar drones that dominate Turkey’s
fleet.fleet.69
~~While Turkish companies have assembled the drones, they have apparently relied on Western~~
~~countries for some key components, including engines, optical sensors, and camera systems.70~~
~~After a Canadian-produced camera system was reportedly found in a Bayraktar TB2 downed in~~
~~Nagorno-Karabakh in October 2020, Canada halted export permits for parts used in Turkish~~
~~drones, concluding in April 2021 that their use was “not consistent with Canadian foreign policy,~~
~~nor end-use assurances given by Turkey.”71 Also in October 2020, a Canadian company whose~~
~~Austrian subsidiary had produced engines for Bayraktar TB2s announced that it would suspend~~

6372 64 The text of a letter from 42 Representatives to Secretary Blinken opposing the F-16 transaction is available at https://pappas.house.gov/media/press-releases/pappas-leads-colleagues-opposing-sale-f-16s-turkey-demands-information-state. 65 Congressional Quarterly Congressional Transcripts (requires paid subscription), available at http://www.cq.com/doc/congressionaltranscripts-6353520?5&search=s5LStXmK. 66 Aaron Stein, “Not a Divorce but a Defense Decoupling: What’s Next for the U.S.-Turkish Alliance,” Aaron Stein, “Not a Divorce but a Defense Decoupling: What’s Next for the U.S.-Turkish Alliance,” War on the
Rocks, October 18, 2021. , October 18, 2021.
6467 Paul Iddon, “Here Are Turkey’s Stopgap Options Until It Can Acquire Fifth-Generation Fighters,” forbes.com, Paul Iddon, “Here Are Turkey’s Stopgap Options Until It Can Acquire Fifth-Generation Fighters,” forbes.com,
March 15, 2021. March 15, 2021.
6568 Dan Gettinger, “Turkey’s military drones: an export product that’s disrupting NATO,” Dan Gettinger, “Turkey’s military drones: an export product that’s disrupting NATO,” Bulletin of the Atomic
Scientists, December 6, 2019. A panel of experts reporting in March 2021 on U.N. Security Council sanctions , December 6, 2019. A panel of experts reporting in March 2021 on U.N. Security Council sanctions
regarding Libya wrote that conflict during 2020 in Libya featured Turkish loitering munitions such as the Kargu-2 regarding Libya wrote that conflict during 2020 in Libya featured Turkish loitering munitions such as the Kargu-2
(produced by Turkish company STM) being programmed to fire autonomously on their targets without human (produced by Turkish company STM) being programmed to fire autonomously on their targets without human
involvement. U.N. Security Council, “Letter dated 8 March 2021 from the Panel of Experts on Libya established involvement. U.N. Security Council, “Letter dated 8 March 2021 from the Panel of Experts on Libya established
pursuant to resolution 1973 (2011) addressed to the President of the Security Council,” S/2021/229, March 8, 2021. pursuant to resolution 1973 (2011) addressed to the President of the Security Council,” S/2021/229, March 8, 2021.
6669 Outzen, Deals, Drones, and National Will. Outzen, Deals, Drones, and National Will.
6770 Itamar Eichner, “Turkey accuses Israel of selling them defective drones,” Itamar Eichner, “Turkey accuses Israel of selling them defective drones,” Ynetnews, June 24, 2018. , June 24, 2018.
6871 Paul Iddon, “Turkey’s Drones Are Coming in All Sizes These Days,” forbes.com, October 4, 2020. Paul Iddon, “Turkey’s Drones Are Coming in All Sizes These Days,” forbes.com, October 4, 2020.
6972 Umar Farooq, “The Second Drone Age: How Turkey Defied the U.S. and Became a Killer Drone Power,” Umar Farooq, “The Second Drone Age: How Turkey Defied the U.S. and Became a Killer Drone Power,” The
Intercept, May 14, 2019. , May 14, 2019.
~~70 “Canadian decision to halt tech exports exposes key weakness in Turkish drone industry,” Turkish Minute, October~~
~~17, 2020.~~
~~71 “Canada scraps export permits for drone technology to Turkey, complains to Ankara,” Reuters, April 12, 2021.~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

10

~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

~~engine deliveries to “countries with unclear usage.”72~~Congressional Research Service 10 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief While Turkish companies have assembled the drones, they have apparently relied on Western countries for some key components, including engines, optical sensors, and camera systems.73 After a Canadian-produced camera system was reportedly found in a Bayraktar TB2 downed in Nagorno-Karabakh in October 2020, Canada halted export permits for parts used in Turkish drones, concluding in April 2021 that their use was “not consistent with Canadian foreign policy, nor end-use assurances given by Turkey.”74 Also in October 2020, a Canadian company whose Austrian subsidiary had produced engines for Bayraktar TB2s announced that it would suspend engine deliveries to “countries with unclear usage.”75 Additionally, Armenian sources raised Additionally, Armenian sources raised
concerns about the possible use of some U.S.-origin components in Bayraktar TB2s,concerns about the possible use of some U.S.-origin components in Bayraktar TB2s,7376 and Senate and Senate
Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Menendez proposed an amendment to the FY2022 National Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Menendez proposed an amendment to the FY2022 National
Defense Authorization Act that would have required a report on recent Turkish drone exports and Defense Authorization Act that would have required a report on recent Turkish drone exports and
whether they contained U.S.-origin components and violated U.S. arms export control law.whether they contained U.S.-origin components and violated U.S. arms export control law.7477
It is unclear how effective Turkish replacements for Western-origin drone components can be It is unclear how effective Turkish replacements for Western-origin drone components can be
going forward. Since 2018, TAI has reportedly been integrating domestically produced engines going forward. Since 2018, TAI has reportedly been integrating domestically produced engines
into its drones, including the Anka-S.into its drones, including the Anka-S.7578 In June 2021, Baykar Technologies officials said that their In June 2021, Baykar Technologies officials said that their
newly produced drones featured Turkish cameras and anticipated having domestically produced newly produced drones featured Turkish cameras and anticipated having domestically produced
engines by the end of the year.engines by the end of the year.7679 Additionally, Ukraine is reportedly producing engines for some Additionally, Ukraine is reportedly producing engines for some
Turkish drones.Turkish drones.7780
Turkish drones’ apparent effectiveness to date—such as in destroying Russian-origin air defense Turkish drones’ apparent effectiveness to date—such as in destroying Russian-origin air defense
~~systems78~~systems81—may have boosted global demand for Turkish defense exports. In addition to —may have boosted global demand for Turkish defense exports. In addition to
Azerbaijan purchasing Bayraktar TB2s that it used in the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, Qatar, Azerbaijan purchasing Bayraktar TB2s that it used in the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, Qatar,
Ukraine, Poland, Morocco, and Ethiopia have reportedly purchased or agreed to purchase TB2s.Ukraine, Poland, Morocco, and Ethiopia have reportedly purchased or agreed to purchase TB2s.7982
Tunisia has signed a deal to purchase Anka-Ss.Tunisia has signed a deal to purchase Anka-Ss.8083 Some other countries also have supposedly Some other countries also have supposedly
expressed interest in Turkish drones.expressed interest in Turkish drones.8184 It is unclear whether the Turkish provision of drones to It is unclear whether the Turkish provision of drones to
other countries—thus involving Turkey at some level in those countries’ political disputes and other countries—thus involving Turkey at some level in those countries’ political disputes and
military conflicts—is a net plus or minus for Turkey’s fragile economy, in light of the potential military conflicts—is a net plus or minus for Turkey’s fragile economy, in light of the potential
~~for Turkey’s actions to isolate it from major powers that represent key sources of trade and~~
~~investment.82~~
~~U.S./NATO Strategic Considerations~~
~~Turkey’s location near several global hotspots has made the continuing availability of its territory~~
~~for the stationing and transport of arms, cargo, and personnel valuable for the United States and~~
~~NATO. In addition to Incirlik Air Base near the southern Turkish city of Adana, other key~~

72 73 “Canadian decision to halt tech exports exposes key weakness in Turkish drone industry,” Turkish Minute, October 17, 2020. 74 “Canada scraps export permits for drone technology to Turkey, complains to Ankara,” Reuters, April 12, 2021. 75 Levon Sevunts, “Bombardier Recreational Products suspends delivery of aircraft engines used on military drones,” Levon Sevunts, “Bombardier Recreational Products suspends delivery of aircraft engines used on military drones,”
Radio Canada International, October 25, 2020. , October 25, 2020.
7376 “How much does the production of Turkish ‘local’ Bayraktar TB2 ATS depend on foreign supplies?” “How much does the production of Turkish ‘local’ Bayraktar TB2 ATS depend on foreign supplies?” Ermeni Haber
Ajansi (translated from Armenian), October 26, 2020. (translated from Armenian), October 26, 2020.
7477 Senator Bob Menendez website, “Chairman Menendez Announces NDAA Amendments to Hold Turkey and Senator Bob Menendez website, “Chairman Menendez Announces NDAA Amendments to Hold Turkey and
Azerbaijan Accountable,” November 4, 2021. Azerbaijan Accountable,” November 4, 2021.
7578 Beth Davidson, “IDEF’19: Anka Aksungur to Fly with Turkish Engine by Year-end,” Beth Davidson, “IDEF’19: Anka Aksungur to Fly with Turkish Engine by Year-end,” AIN Online, May 1, 2019. , May 1, 2019.
7679 Marson and Forrest, “Low-Cost Armed Drones Reshape War and Geopolitics.” Marson and Forrest, “Low-Cost Armed Drones Reshape War and Geopolitics.”
7780 Aaron Stein, “From Ankara with Implications: Turkish Drones and Alliance Entrapment,” Aaron Stein, “From Ankara with Implications: Turkish Drones and Alliance Entrapment,” War on the Rocks, ,
December 15, 2021. December 15, 2021.
7881 Seth Frantzman, “Russian air defense systems outmatched by Turkish drones in Syria and Libya,” Seth Frantzman, “Russian air defense systems outmatched by Turkish drones in Syria and Libya,” Long War Journal
(Foundation for Defense of Democracies), June 10, 2020. (Foundation for Defense of Democracies), June 10, 2020.
7982 Aishwarya Rakesh, “How Turkey’s Bayraktar Drones Became an International Success,” defenseworld.net, May 27, Aishwarya Rakesh, “How Turkey’s Bayraktar Drones Became an International Success,” defenseworld.net, May 27,
2021; “Turkey expands armed drone sales to Ethiopia and Morocco – sources,” 2021; “Turkey expands armed drone sales to Ethiopia and Morocco – sources,” Reuters, October 14, 2021. , October 14, 2021.
8083 “After big wins, interest in Turkish combat drones soars,” “After big wins, interest in Turkish combat drones soars,” Agence France Presse, March 19, 2021. , March 19, 2021.
8184 See, for example, “Armed with drones, Turkey explores African arms sales,” See, for example, “Armed with drones, Turkey explores African arms sales,” Hurriyet Daily News, December 15, , December 15,
2021. 2021.
~~82 See, for example, Metin Gurcan, “Turkey’s foreign policy becoming alarmingly militarized,” Al-Monitor, September~~
~~22, 2020; Sinan Ulgen, “A Weak Economy Won’t Stop Turkey’s Activist Foreign Policy,” foreignpolicy.com, October~~
~~6, 2020.~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

11

~~link to page 22 link to page 16~~ ~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

Congressional Research Service 11 link to page 22 link to page 17 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief for Turkey’s actions to isolate it from major powers that represent key sources of trade and investment.85 U.S./NATO Strategic Considerations Turkey’s location near several global hotspots has made the continuing availability of its territory for the stationing and transport of arms, cargo, and personnel valuable for the United States and NATO. In addition to Incirlik Air Base near the southern Turkish city of Adana, other key U.S./NATO sites include an early warning missile defense radar in eastern Turkey and a NATO U.S./NATO sites include an early warning missile defense radar in eastern Turkey and a NATO
ground forces command in Izmir (seeground forces command in Izmir (see Figure A-3). .
From Turkey’s perspective, NATO’s traditional importance has been to mitigate Turkish concerns From Turkey’s perspective, NATO’s traditional importance has been to mitigate Turkish concerns
about encroachment by neighbors, as was the case with the Soviet Union’s aggressive post-World about encroachment by neighbors, as was the case with the Soviet Union’s aggressive post-World
War II posturing. Some similar Turkish concerns—though somewhat less pronounced—may stem War II posturing. Some similar Turkish concerns—though somewhat less pronounced—may stem
from Russia’s ongoing regional involvement in places such as Syria and Ukraine, and may partly from Russia’s ongoing regional involvement in places such as Syria and Ukraine, and may partly
motivate recent Turkish military operations to frustrate some Russian objectives in various motivate recent Turkish military operations to frustrate some Russian objectives in various
conflict arenas.conflict arenas.8386
As a result of growing tensions between Turkey and Western countries, and questions about the As a result of growing tensions between Turkey and Western countries, and questions about the
safety and utility of Turkish territory for U.S. and NATO assets, some observers have advocated safety and utility of Turkish territory for U.S. and NATO assets, some observers have advocated
exploring alternative basing arrangements in the region.exploring alternative basing arrangements in the region.8487 Some reports suggest that expanded or Some reports suggest that expanded or
potentially expanded U.S. military presences in places such as Greece, Cyprus, Jordan and potentially expanded U.S. military presences in places such as Greece, Cyprus, Jordan and
Romania might be connected with concerns about Turkey.Romania might be connected with concerns about Turkey.8588
Additionally, Turkish actions in opposition to the interests of other U.S. allies and partners in the Additionally, Turkish actions in opposition to the interests of other U.S. allies and partners in the
Eastern Mediterranean (see Eastern Mediterranean (see “Cyprus, Greece, and Eastern Mediterranean Natural Gas” below)— below)—
particularly over the past two years—have led U.S. officials to encourage cooperation among particularly over the past two years—have led U.S. officials to encourage cooperation among
those allies and partners.those allies and partners.8689 In 2020, the Trump Administration waived restrictions on the U.S. sale In 2020, the Trump Administration waived restrictions on the U.S. sale
of non-lethal defense articles and services to the Republic of Cyprus, effectively ending a U.S. of non-lethal defense articles and services to the Republic of Cyprus, effectively ending a U.S.
arms embargo that had dated back to 1987, and attracting criticism from Turkish officials.arms embargo that had dated back to 1987, and attracting criticism from Turkish officials.8790
Turkey’s influence in the Black Sea littoral region and its relationships with European countries Turkey’s influence in the Black Sea littoral region and its relationships with European countries
bordering Russia make its actions in this sphere important for U.S. interests. Ongoing Turkish bordering Russia make its actions in this sphere important for U.S. interests. Ongoing Turkish
defense cooperation with or arms sales to Ukraine, Poland, Georgia, and Azerbaijan may present defense cooperation with or arms sales to Ukraine, Poland, Georgia, and Azerbaijan may present
opportunities to make renewed common cause between the United States and Turkey to counter opportunities to make renewed common cause between the United States and Turkey to counter
Russia.Russia.8891 Alternatively, Turkey’s interactions with these other countries could possibly check both Alternatively, Turkey’s interactions with these other countries could possibly check both
~~U.S. and Russian ambitions, or increase regional tensions potentially leading toward conflict.89 A~~
~~case in point will be how Turkey regulates and controls other countries’ maritime access to and~~
~~from the Black Sea—a limited privilege granted to Turkey in the Montreux Convention of 1936~~
~~(with provisions to give Turkey greater control when at war).90~~

83 85 See, for example, Metin Gurcan, “Turkey’s foreign policy becoming alarmingly militarized,” Al-Monitor, September 22, 2020; Sinan Ulgen, “A Weak Economy Won’t Stop Turkey’s Activist Foreign Policy,” foreignpolicy.com, October 6, 2020. 86 Prothero, “Turkey’s Erdogan has been humiliating Putin all year.” Prothero, “Turkey’s Erdogan has been humiliating Putin all year.”
8487 See, for example, Xander Snyder, “Beyond Incirlik,” See, for example, Xander Snyder, “Beyond Incirlik,” Geopolitical Futures, April 19, 2019. , April 19, 2019.
8588 Marc Pierini and Francesco Siccardi, “Understanding Turkey’s Direction: Three Scenarios,” Carnegie Europe, Marc Pierini and Francesco Siccardi, “Understanding Turkey’s Direction: Three Scenarios,” Carnegie Europe,
December 9, 2021; “Pentagon pushes back on claim that US to leave Turkey’s Incirlik base,” December 9, 2021; “Pentagon pushes back on claim that US to leave Turkey’s Incirlik base,” Al-Monitor, September , September
16, 2020; Joseph Trevithick, “Docs Show US to Massively Expand Footprint at Jordanian Air Base amid Spats with 16, 2020; Joseph Trevithick, “Docs Show US to Massively Expand Footprint at Jordanian Air Base amid Spats with
Turkey, Iraq,” Turkey, Iraq,” The Drive, January 14, 2019. , January 14, 2019.
8689 Rauf Baker, “The EastMed Gas and Philia Forums: Reimagining Cooperation in the Mediterranean,” Rauf Baker, “The EastMed Gas and Philia Forums: Reimagining Cooperation in the Mediterranean,” Fikra Forum, ,
Washington Institute for Near East Policy, March 18, 2021. Washington Institute for Near East Policy, March 18, 2021.
8790 “Pompeo says US will lift arms embargo on Cyprus, Turkey furious,” “Pompeo says US will lift arms embargo on Cyprus, Turkey furious,” Reuters, September 2, 2020. , September 2, 2020.
8891 See, for example, Gonul Tol and Yoruk Isik, “Turkey-NATO ties are problematic, but there is one bright spot,” See, for example, Gonul Tol and Yoruk Isik, “Turkey-NATO ties are problematic, but there is one bright spot,”
Middle East Institute, February 16, 2021. Middle East Institute, February 16, 2021.
~~89 See, for example, Stein, “From Ankara with Implications.”~~
~~90 Text of the convention available at https://cil.nus.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/formidable/18/1936-Convention-~~
~~Regarding-the-Regime-of-the-Straits.pdf.~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

12

~~link to page 23~~ ~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

~~Regional Conflicts and Disputes~~
~~Syria91~~Congressional Research Service 12 link to page 23 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief U.S. and Russian ambitions, or increase regional tensions potentially leading toward conflict.92 A case in point will be how Turkey regulates and controls other countries’ maritime access to and from the Black Sea—a limited privilege granted to Turkey in the Montreux Convention of 1936 (with provisions to give Turkey greater control when at war).93 Regional Conflicts and Disputes Syria94
Turkey’s involvement in Syria’s conflict since 2011 has been complicated and costly and has Turkey’s involvement in Syria’s conflict since 2011 has been complicated and costly and has
severely strained U.S.-Turkey ties.severely strained U.S.-Turkey ties.9295 Turkey’s priorities in Syria’s civil war have evolved during Turkey’s priorities in Syria’s civil war have evolved during
the course of the conflict. While Turkey still opposes Syrian President Bashar al Asad, it has the course of the conflict. While Turkey still opposes Syrian President Bashar al Asad, it has
engaged in a mix of coordination and competition with Russia and Iran (which support Asad) on engaged in a mix of coordination and competition with Russia and Iran (which support Asad) on
some matters since intervening militarily in Syria starting in August 2016. Turkey and the United some matters since intervening militarily in Syria starting in August 2016. Turkey and the United
States have engaged in similarly inconsistent interactions in northern Syria east of the Euphrates States have engaged in similarly inconsistent interactions in northern Syria east of the Euphrates
River where U.S. forces have been based. River where U.S. forces have been based.
Turkey’s chief objective has been to thwart the Syrian Kurdish People’s Protection Units (YPG) Turkey’s chief objective has been to thwart the Syrian Kurdish People’s Protection Units (YPG)
from establishing an autonomous area along Syria’s northern border with Turkey. Turkey’s from establishing an autonomous area along Syria’s northern border with Turkey. Turkey’s
government considers the YPG and its political counterpart, the Democratic Union Party (PYD), government considers the YPG and its political counterpart, the Democratic Union Party (PYD),
to be a major threat to Turkish security because of Turkish concerns that YPG/PYD gains have to be a major threat to Turkish security because of Turkish concerns that YPG/PYD gains have
emboldened the PKK (which has links to the YPG/PYD) in its domestic conflict with Turkish emboldened the PKK (which has links to the YPG/PYD) in its domestic conflict with Turkish
authorities.authorities.9396 The YPG/PYD has a leading role within the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), an The YPG/PYD has a leading role within the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), an
umbrella group including Arabs and other non-Kurdish elements that became the main U.S. umbrella group including Arabs and other non-Kurdish elements that became the main U.S.
ground force partner against the Islamic State in 2015. Turkish-led military operations in October ground force partner against the Islamic State in 2015. Turkish-led military operations in October
2019 to seize areas of northeastern Syria from the SDF—after President Trump agreed to have 2019 to seize areas of northeastern Syria from the SDF—after President Trump agreed to have
U.S. Special Forces pull back from the border area—led to major criticism of and proposed action U.S. Special Forces pull back from the border area—led to major criticism of and proposed action
against Turkey in Congress.against Turkey in Congress.9497
In areas of northern Syria that Turkey has occupied since 2016 (see In areas of northern Syria that Turkey has occupied since 2016 (see Figure A-4), Turkey has set , Turkey has set
up local councils. These councils and associated security forces provide public services in these up local councils. These councils and associated security forces provide public services in these
areas with funding, oversight, and training from Turkish officials. Questions persist about future areas with funding, oversight, and training from Turkish officials. Questions persist about future
governance and Turkey’s overarching role. governance and Turkey’s overarching role.
The Turkish military remains in a standoff with Russia and the Syrian government over the future The Turkish military remains in a standoff with Russia and the Syrian government over the future
of Syria’s northwestern province of Idlib, the last part of the country held by anti-Asad groups of Syria’s northwestern province of Idlib, the last part of the country held by anti-Asad groups
(including some with links to Al Qaeda). Turkey deployed troops to Idlib to protect it from Syrian (including some with links to Al Qaeda). Turkey deployed troops to Idlib to protect it from Syrian
government forces and prevent further refugee flows into Turkey. A limited outbreak of conflict government forces and prevent further refugee flows into Turkey. A limited outbreak of conflict
in 2020 displaced hundreds of thousands of Syrian civilians and produced casualties on many in 2020 displaced hundreds of thousands of Syrian civilians and produced casualties on many
sides. Russian willingness to back Syrian operations in Idlib perhaps stems in part from Turkey’s sides. Russian willingness to back Syrian operations in Idlib perhaps stems in part from Turkey’s
~~unwillingness or inability to enforce a 2018 Turkey-Russia agreement by removing heavy~~
~~weapons and “radical terrorist groups” from the province.95~~
~~Cyprus, Greece, and Eastern Mediterranean Natural Gas~~
~~A dispute during the past decade between Turkey and the Republic of Cyprus (ROC) about~~
~~Eastern Mediterranean exploration for natural gas reserves (see textbox below for broader~~

91 92 See, for example, Stein, “From Ankara with Implications.” 93 Text of the convention available at https://cil.nus.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/formidable/18/1936-Convention-Regarding-the-Regime-of-the-Straits.pdf. 94 See CRS Report RL33487, See CRS Report RL33487, Armed Conflict in Syria: Overview and U.S. Response, coordinated by Carla E. Humud. , coordinated by Carla E. Humud.
9295 For background, see Burak Kadercan, “Making Sense of Turkey’s Syria Strategy: A ‘Turkish Tragedy’ in the For background, see Burak Kadercan, “Making Sense of Turkey’s Syria Strategy: A ‘Turkish Tragedy’ in the
Making,” Making,” War on the Rocks, August 4, 2017. , August 4, 2017.
9396 See, e.g., Soner Cagaptay, “U.S. Safe Zone Deal Can Help Turkey Come to Terms with the PKK and YPG,” See, e.g., Soner Cagaptay, “U.S. Safe Zone Deal Can Help Turkey Come to Terms with the PKK and YPG,”
Washington Institute for Near East Policy, August 7, 2019. Washington Institute for Near East Policy, August 7, 2019.
9497 Rachel Oswald, “Sanctions on Turkey go front and center as Congress returns,” rollcall.com, October 15, 2019. Rachel Oswald, “Sanctions on Turkey go front and center as Congress returns,” rollcall.com, October 15, 2019.
~~95 Text of agreement available at https://www.thenational.ae/world/mena/full-text-of-turkey-russia-memorandum-on-~~
~~idlib-revealed-1.771953.~~
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

13 13

link to page 24 link to page 24 link to page 24 link to page 24 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

unwillingness or inability to enforce a 2018 Turkey-Russia agreement by removing heavy weapons and “radical terrorist groups” from the province.98 Cyprus, Greece, and Eastern Mediterranean Natural Gas A dispute during the past decade between Turkey and the Republic of Cyprus (ROC) about Eastern Mediterranean exploration for natural gas reserves (see text box below for broader historical context) has brought the ROC, Greece, Israel, and Egypt closer together.historical context) has brought the ROC, Greece, Israel, and Egypt closer together.9699 Turkey has Turkey has
objected to Greek Cypriot transactions in the offshore energy sector because they have not objected to Greek Cypriot transactions in the offshore energy sector because they have not
involved the de facto Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) that controls the northern involved the de facto Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) that controls the northern
one-third of the island. Turkey also has supported Turkish Cypriot claims to an exclusive one-third of the island. Turkey also has supported Turkish Cypriot claims to an exclusive
economic zone around part of the island. The ROC, Greece, and Israel have discussed possible economic zone around part of the island. The ROC, Greece, and Israel have discussed possible
cooperation to export gas finds to Europe via a pipeline bypassing Turkey,cooperation to export gas finds to Europe via a pipeline bypassing Turkey,97100 and an Eastern and an Eastern
Mediterranean Gas Forum officially established itself in 2021, with the ROC, Greece, Israel, and Mediterranean Gas Forum officially established itself in 2021, with the ROC, Greece, Israel, and
Egypt among the founding members (and the United States and EU as observers). Egypt among the founding members (and the United States and EU as observers).
Turkish Disputes Regarding Greece and Cyprus: Historical ~~Background98~~Background101
Since the 1970s, disputes between Greece and Turkey over territorial rights in the Aegean Sea and broader Since the 1970s, disputes between Greece and Turkey over territorial rights in the Aegean Sea and broader
Eastern Mediterranean have been a major point of contention, even bringing the sides close to military conflict on Eastern Mediterranean have been a major point of contention, even bringing the sides close to military conflict on
several occasions. The disputes, which have their roots in territorial changes after World War I, revolve around several occasions. The disputes, which have their roots in territorial changes after World War I, revolve around
contested borders between each country’s territorial waters, national airspace, exclusive economic zone (EEZ), contested borders between each country’s territorial waters, national airspace, exclusive economic zone (EEZ),
and continental shelf. These tensions are related to and further complicated by one of the region’s major and continental shelf. These tensions are related to and further complicated by one of the region’s major
unresolved conflicts, the de facto political division of Cyprus along ethnic lines that dates from a 1974 conflict. The unresolved conflicts, the de facto political division of Cyprus along ethnic lines that dates from a 1974 conflict. The
internationally recognized ROC, which has close ties to Greece, claims jurisdiction over the entire island, but its internationally recognized ROC, which has close ties to Greece, claims jurisdiction over the entire island, but its
effective administrative control is limited to the southern two-thirds, where Greek Cypriots comprise a majority. effective administrative control is limited to the southern two-thirds, where Greek Cypriots comprise a majority.
Turkish Cypriots administer the northern third and are backed by Turkey, including a Turkish military contingent Turkish Cypriots administer the northern third and are backed by Turkey, including a Turkish military contingent
there since the 1974 conflict.there since the 1974 conflict.99102 In 1983, Turkish Cypriot leaders proclaimed this part of the island the TRNC, In 1983, Turkish Cypriot leaders proclaimed this part of the island the TRNC,
although no country other than Turkey recognizes it. although no country other than Turkey recognizes it.
In late 2019, the Turkey-Cyprus dispute became intertwined with some In late 2019, the Turkey-Cyprus dispute became intertwined with some ~~longstanding~~long-standing Turkey- Turkey-
Greece disagreements (discussed in the Greece disagreements (discussed in the ~~textbox~~text box above) when Turkey signed an agreement with above) when Turkey signed an agreement with
Libya’s then-Government of National Accord (GNA) on maritime boundaries (seLibya’s then-Government of National Accord (GNA) on maritime boundaries (see Figure A-
5).~~100~~103 The dispute increased Turkey-Greece naval tensions, especially after Greece and Egypt The dispute increased Turkey-Greece naval tensions, especially after Greece and Egypt
reached a maritime boundary agreement in August 2020 rivaling the 2019 Turkey-Libya deal.reached a maritime boundary agreement in August 2020 rivaling the 2019 Turkey-Libya deal.~~101~~
~~Efforts by individual European governments, the EU, NATO, and the United States to de-escalate~~
~~tensions have highlighted competing international interests and objectives.102 Greece and the~~
~~ROC are EU members, but Turkey is not, and prospects for its accession are dim for the~~
~~foreseeable future. Greece and Turkey are NATO members, but the ROC is not.~~
~~Turkey-Greece talks on territorial disputes resumed in January 2021 after a five-year hiatus, but~~
~~significant progress on the underlying issues of dispute remains elusive. Additionally, preliminary~~

96104 98 Text of agreement available at https://www.thenational.ae/world/mena/full-text-of-turkey-russia-memorandum-on-idlib-revealed-1.771953. 99 Yaroslav Trofimov, “Turkey, Rivals Square Off Over Gas Finds,” Yaroslav Trofimov, “Turkey, Rivals Square Off Over Gas Finds,” Wall Street Journal, August 3, 2020. , August 3, 2020.
97100 “Battling over boundaries,” “Battling over boundaries,” Economist, August 22, 2020. The feasibility of such a pipeline is unclear. Sue Surkes, , August 22, 2020. The feasibility of such a pipeline is unclear. Sue Surkes,
“Mistake to leave Turkey out of new East Med gas club – international expert,” “Mistake to leave Turkey out of new East Med gas club – international expert,” Times of Israel, September 27, 2020. , September 27, 2020.
98101 For more information, see CRS Report R41368, For more information, see CRS Report R41368, Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations, by Jim Zanotti and Clayton , by Jim Zanotti and Clayton
Thomas and CRS Report R41136, Thomas and CRS Report R41136, Cyprus: Reunification Proving Elusive, by Vincent L. Morelli. , by Vincent L. Morelli.
99102 Turkey retains between 30,000 and 40,000 troops on the island (supplemented by several thousand Turkish Cypriot Turkey retains between 30,000 and 40,000 troops on the island (supplemented by several thousand Turkish Cypriot
soldiers). This presence is countered by a Greek Cypriot force of approximately 12,000 with reported access to 50,000 soldiers). This presence is countered by a Greek Cypriot force of approximately 12,000 with reported access to 50,000
reserves. “Cyprus—Army,” reserves. “Cyprus—Army,” Jane’s Group UK, October 2019. The United Nations maintains a peacekeeping mission , October 2019. The United Nations maintains a peacekeeping mission
(UNFICYP) of approximately 900 personnel within a buffer zone headquartered in Cyprus’s divided capital of Nicosia. (UNFICYP) of approximately 900 personnel within a buffer zone headquartered in Cyprus’s divided capital of Nicosia.
The United Kingdom maintains approximately 3,000 personnel at two sovereign base areas on the southern portion of The United Kingdom maintains approximately 3,000 personnel at two sovereign base areas on the southern portion of
the island at Akrotiri and Dhekelia. the island at Akrotiri and Dhekelia.
~~100~~103 See also “Turkish-Greek Aegean Dispute” at globalsecurity.org. See also “Turkish-Greek Aegean Dispute” at globalsecurity.org.
~~101~~104 Michael Tanchum, “How Did the Eastern Mediterranean Become the Eye of a Geopolitical Storm?” Michael Tanchum, “How Did the Eastern Mediterranean Become the Eye of a Geopolitical Storm?”
foreignpolicy.com, August 18, 2020. foreignpolicy.com, August 18, 2020.
~~102 For example, The United States has not ratified the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), though it~~
~~does recognize UNCLOS as a codification of customary international law.~~Congressional Research Service 14 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief Efforts by individual European governments, the EU, NATO, and the United States to de-escalate tensions have highlighted competing international interests and objectives.105 Greece and the Greece and the ROC are EU members, but Turkey is not, and prospects for its accession are dim for the foreseeable future. Greece and Turkey are NATO members, but the ROC is not. Turkey-Greece talks on territorial disputes resumed in January 2021 after a five-year hiatus, but significant progress on the underlying issues of dispute remains elusive. Additionally, preliminary ~~ROC have ratified~~
~~UNCLOS; Turkey has not.~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

14

~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

United Nations-led talks on Cyprus stalled in April 2021.United Nations-led talks on Cyprus stalled in April 2021.~~103~~106 ROC President Nicos Anastasiades ROC President Nicos Anastasiades
has said he will not negotiate as long as the TRNC’s leader Ersin Tatar, who assumed office in has said he will not negotiate as long as the TRNC’s leader Ersin Tatar, who assumed office in
October 2020, advocates Turkish Cypriot independence and a “two-state solution.”October 2020, advocates Turkish Cypriot independence and a “two-state solution.”~~104~~107 President President
Erdogan has echoed Tatar’s advocacy of a two-state solution.Erdogan has echoed Tatar’s advocacy of a two-state solution.~~105~~108
Middle East Rivalries and Libya
In the Middle East, Sunni Arab governments that support traditional authoritarian governance In the Middle East, Sunni Arab governments that support traditional authoritarian governance
models in the region—notably Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), and Egypt—models in the region—notably Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), and Egypt—
regard Turkey with suspicion, largely because of the Turkish government’s sympathies for regard Turkey with suspicion, largely because of the Turkish government’s sympathies for
Islamist political groups and its close relationship with Qatar.Islamist political groups and its close relationship with Qatar.~~106~~109 Ties with Turkey have bolstered Ties with Turkey have bolstered
Qatar to the extent other Arab states have sought to isolate it, and while Qatar’s efforts to Qatar to the extent other Arab states have sought to isolate it, and while Qatar’s efforts to
reintegrate with its Arab Gulf neighbors may somewhat limit its cooperation with Turkey, Qatari reintegrate with its Arab Gulf neighbors may somewhat limit its cooperation with Turkey, Qatari
resources have helped Turkey strengthen its troubled financial position and support its regional resources have helped Turkey strengthen its troubled financial position and support its regional
military posture.military posture.~~107~~110 Further signs of tension between Turkey and Sunni Arab states come from a Further signs of tension between Turkey and Sunni Arab states come from a
Turkish military presence at bases in Qatar and Somalia.Turkish military presence at bases in Qatar and Somalia.~~108~~111
Libya represents another aspect of Turkey’s rivalry with these states. Turkey has played a Libya represents another aspect of Turkey’s rivalry with these states. Turkey has played a
prominent role in conflict in Libya since late 2019, when Turkish officials reached maritime prominent role in conflict in Libya since late 2019, when Turkish officials reached maritime
boundary and security agreements with Libya’s Government of National Accord (GNA), which boundary and security agreements with Libya’s Government of National Accord (GNA), which
was recognized at that time by the United States and the U.N. Security Council. Turkish military was recognized at that time by the United States and the U.N. Security Council. Turkish military
personnel then began providing advice and material support (including drone aircraft and Syrian personnel then began providing advice and material support (including drone aircraft and Syrian
mercenaries) to Islamist-friendly western Libya-based forces fighting against Khalifa Haftar’s mercenaries) to Islamist-friendly western Libya-based forces fighting against Khalifa Haftar’s
Libyan National Army (LNA) movement.Libyan National Army (LNA) movement.~~109~~112 Egypt, the UAE, Russia, and others have backed Egypt, the UAE, Russia, and others have backed
Haftar’s LNA movement. After a U.N.-brokered cease-fire was reached in October 2020, Libyans Haftar’s LNA movement. After a U.N.-brokered cease-fire was reached in October 2020, Libyans
approved a new Government of National Unity (GNU) in March 2021. While the terms of the approved a new Government of National Unity (GNU) in March 2021. While the terms of the
~~cease-fire and U.N. Security Council Resolution 2570 call for all mercenaries and foreign fighters~~
~~to be withdrawn from Libya, Turkey has reportedly delayed taking action, perhaps partly because~~
~~of concerns about the possible outcome of Libya’s scheduled December 2021 presidential~~
~~election.110~~
~~Turkey’s involvement in Libya increased the overlap between Turkey’s disputes in the Eastern~~
~~Mediterranean and its rivalry with other states in the region. In 2021, Turkey has made some~~
~~headway in softening tensions with Sunni Arab governments, highlighted by a November 2021~~

~~103~~ 105 For example, The United States has not ratified the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), though it does recognize UNCLOS as a codification of customary international law. Greece and the ROC have ratified UNCLOS; Turkey has not. 106 John Psaropoulos, “Cyprus’ reunification: What next after failed talks?” John Psaropoulos, “Cyprus’ reunification: What next after failed talks?” Al Jazeera, June 7, 2021., June 7, 2021. The U.N. The U.N.
Security Council reaffirmed its support for “an enduring, comprehensive, and just settlement based on a bicommunal, Security Council reaffirmed its support for “an enduring, comprehensive, and just settlement based on a bicommunal,
bizonal federation with political equality” in a resolution adopted on January 29, 2021 (UNSC Resolution 2561/2021). bizonal federation with political equality” in a resolution adopted on January 29, 2021 (UNSC Resolution 2561/2021).
~~104~~107 “After another Cyprus talks collapse, Anastasiades walking away,” “After another Cyprus talks collapse, Anastasiades walking away,” National Herald, May 3, 2021. , May 3, 2021.
~~105~~108 Dorian Jones, “Erdogan Calls for Two-state Solution on Cyprus,” Dorian Jones, “Erdogan Calls for Two-state Solution on Cyprus,” Voice of America, July 20, 2021. , July 20, 2021.
~~106~~109 Flanagan et al., Flanagan et al., Turkey’s Nationalist Course; Andrew England, et al., “UAE vs Turkey: the regional rivalries pitting ; Andrew England, et al., “UAE vs Turkey: the regional rivalries pitting
MBZ against Erdogan,” MBZ against Erdogan,” Financial Times, October 26, 2020. , October 26, 2020.
~~107~~110 Fehim Tastekin, “Turkey’s good relations with Qatar may not be enough for Erdogan,” Fehim Tastekin, “Turkey’s good relations with Qatar may not be enough for Erdogan,” Al-Monitor, December 8, , December 8,
2021; Ibrahim Sunnetci, “Turkey and Qatar: Foul-Weather Friends!” 2021; Ibrahim Sunnetci, “Turkey and Qatar: Foul-Weather Friends!” Defence Turkey, vol. 14, issue 98, 2020, pp. 34-, vol. 14, issue 98, 2020, pp. 34-
47. 47.
~~108~~111 Sunnetci, “Turkey and Qatar”; “Turkey to train 1/3 of entire Somali military, envoy says,” Sunnetci, “Turkey and Qatar”; “Turkey to train 1/3 of entire Somali military, envoy says,” Daily Sabah, August 4, , August 4,
2020. 2020.
~~109~~112 Department of Defense Office of the Inspector General, East Africa Counterterrorism Operation, North and West Department of Defense Office of the Inspector General, East Africa Counterterrorism Operation, North and West
Africa Counterterrorism Operation, Lead Inspector General Report to the United States Congress, January 1, 2020-Africa Counterterrorism Operation, Lead Inspector General Report to the United States Congress, January 1, 2020-
March 30, 2020, July 16, 2020. March 30, 2020, July 16, 2020.
~~110 Fehim Tastekin, “Libya’s elections could hinge on Turkey’s next move,” Al-Monitor, November 23, 2021.~~
~~Congressional Research Service~~

15

~~Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief~~

Congressional Research Service 15 Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief cease-fire and U.N. Security Council Resolution 2570 call for all mercenaries and foreign fighters to be withdrawn from Libya, Turkey has reportedly delayed taking action, perhaps partly because of uncertainty about Libya’s future leadership and political course.113 Turkey’s involvement in Libya increased the overlap between Turkey’s disputes in the Eastern Mediterranean and its rivalry with other states in the region. In 2021, Turkey has made some headway in softening tensions with Sunni Arab governments, highlighted by a November 2021 visit to Ankara by UAE de facto leader Shaykh Mohammad bin Zayid al Nuhayyan and visit to Ankara by UAE de facto leader Shaykh Mohammad bin Zayid al Nuhayyan and
accompanying Turkey-UAE agreements on economic cooperation and investment.accompanying Turkey-UAE agreements on economic cooperation and investment.~~111~~114 Prospects Prospects
for broader regional rapprochement remain unclear, including with Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and for broader regional rapprochement remain unclear, including with Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and
Israel.Israel.~~112~~115 Turkey maintains diplomatic ties and significant levels of trade with Israel, but Turkey- Turkey maintains diplomatic ties and significant levels of trade with Israel, but Turkey-
Israel relations have deteriorated significantly during Erdogan’s rule.Israel relations have deteriorated significantly during Erdogan’s rule.~~113~~116
Outlook and U.S. Options
The future of U.S.-Turkey relations could depend on a number of factors, including the following: The future of U.S.-Turkey relations could depend on a number of factors, including the following:
 whether President Erdogan is able to maintain control in the country given its  whether President Erdogan is able to maintain control in the country given its
currency crisis and various human rights and rule of law concerns. currency crisis and various human rights and rule of law concerns.
 whether Turkey makes its Russian S-400 system fully operational and purchases  whether Turkey makes its Russian S-400 system fully operational and purchases
additional Russian arms; additional Russian arms;
 how various regional crises (Syria, Libya, Eastern Mediterranean disputes with  how various regional crises (Syria, Libya, Eastern Mediterranean disputes with
Greece and Cyprus) develop and influence Turkey’s relationships with key actors Greece and Cyprus) develop and influence Turkey’s relationships with key actors
(including the United States, Russia, China, the European Union, Israel, Iran, and (including the United States, Russia, China, the European Union, Israel, Iran, and
Sunni Arab governments); and Sunni Arab governments); and
 whether Turkey can project power and create its own sphere of influence using  whether Turkey can project power and create its own sphere of influence using
military and economic cooperation (including defense exports). military and economic cooperation (including defense exports).
Administration and congressional actions regarding Turkey can have implications for bilateral Administration and congressional actions regarding Turkey can have implications for bilateral
ties, U.S. political-military options in the region, and Turkey’s strategic orientation and financial ties, U.S. political-military options in the region, and Turkey’s strategic orientation and financial
well-being. These actions could include responding to Turkey’s late 2021 request to purchase and well-being. These actions could include responding to Turkey’s late 2021 request to purchase and
upgrade F-16s, evaluating and possibly changing CAATSA sanctions, assessing U.S./NATO upgrade F-16s, evaluating and possibly changing CAATSA sanctions, assessing U.S./NATO
basing options, and balancing relations with Turkey and its regional rivals. U.S. actions related to basing options, and balancing relations with Turkey and its regional rivals. U.S. actions related to
Turkey’s acquisition of the S-400 also could affect U.S. relations with respect to other key Turkey’s acquisition of the S-400 also could affect U.S. relations with respect to other key
partners who have purchased or may purchase advanced weapons from Russia—including India, partners who have purchased or may purchase advanced weapons from Russia—including India,
Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Qatar. Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Qatar.
How closely the U.S. government might engage Erdogan’s government could depend on U.S. How closely the U.S. government might engage Erdogan’s government could depend on U.S.
perceptions of his popular legitimacy, likely staying power, and the extent to which a successor perceptions of his popular legitimacy, likely staying power, and the extent to which a successor
might change his policies in light of geopolitical, historical, and economic considerations. might change his policies in light of geopolitical, historical, and economic considerations.
Support for Erdogan relative to other key domestic figures may hinge partly on national security Support for Erdogan relative to other key domestic figures may hinge partly on national security
and economic conditions and developments, and partly on ideological or group identity and economic conditions and developments, and partly on ideological or group identity
considerations stemming from ethnicity, religion, gender, and class. considerations stemming from ethnicity, religion, gender, and class.

~~111~~113 “Turkey calls for preserving calm in Libya after elections delay,” Xinhua, December 24, 2021. 114 Orhan Coskun, “Turkey, UAE sign investment accords worth billions of dollars,” Orhan Coskun, “Turkey, UAE sign investment accords worth billions of dollars,” Reuters, November 24, 2021. , November 24, 2021.
~~112~~115 “Erdogan “Erdogan'’s visit to Qatar to yield deals but no MbS meeting,” s visit to Qatar to yield deals but no MbS meeting,” Reuters, December 6, 2021; “Erdogan says Turkey , December 6, 2021; “Erdogan says Turkey
seeking to mend troubled ties with Israel,” seeking to mend troubled ties with Israel,” Agence France Presse and and Times of Israel, November 29, 2021. , November 29, 2021.
~~113~~116 See CRS Report R41368, See CRS Report R41368, Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations, by Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas. , by Jim Zanotti and Clayton Thomas.
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

16 16

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Appendix. Maps, Facts, and Figures
Figure A-1. Turkey at a Glance

Geography
Area: 783,562 sq km (302,535 sq. mile), slightly larger than Texas 783,562 sq km (302,535 sq. mile), slightly larger than Texas
People
Population: 82,482,383. Most populous cities (2020): Istanbul 15.2 mil, Ankara 5.1 mil, Izmir 3.0 82,482,383. Most populous cities (2020): Istanbul 15.2 mil, Ankara 5.1 mil, Izmir 3.0
mil, Bursa 2.0 mil, Adana 1.8 mil, Gaziantep 1.7 mil. mil, Bursa 2.0 mil, Adana 1.8 mil, Gaziantep 1.7 mil.
% of Population 14 or Younger: 23.4% 23.4%
Ethnic Groups: Turks 70%-75%; Kurds 19%; Other minorities 7%-12% (2016) Turks 70%-75%; Kurds 19%; Other minorities 7%-12% (2016)
Religion: Muslim 99.8% (mostly Sunni), Others (mainly Christian and Jewish) 0.2% Muslim 99.8% (mostly Sunni), Others (mainly Christian and Jewish) 0.2%
Literacy: 96.7% (male 99.1%, female 94.4%) (2019) 96.7% (male 99.1%, female 94.4%) (2019)
Economy
GDP Per Capita (at purchasing power parity): $31,080 $31,080
Real GDP Growth: 8.0% (2021), 3.3% (2022 proj.) 8.0% (2021), 3.3% (2022 proj.)
Inflation: 18.9% 18.9%
Unemployment: 13.0% 13.0%
Budget Deficit as % of GDP: 3.1% 3.1%
Public Debt as % of GDP: 39.4% 39.4%
Current Account Deficit as % of GDP: 2.4% 2.4%
~~Source~~Sources: Graphic created by CRS. Map boundaries and information generated by Hannah Fischer using Graphic created by CRS. Map boundaries and information generated by Hannah Fischer using
Department of State Boundaries (2011); Esri (2014); ArcWorld (2014); DeLorme (2014). Fact information (2021 Department of State Boundaries (2011); Esri (2014); ArcWorld (2014); DeLorme (2014). Fact information (2021
estimates or forecasts unless otherwise specified) from International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook estimates or forecasts unless otherwise specified) from International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook
Database; Economist Intelligence Unit; and Central Intelligence Agency, Database; Economist Intelligence Unit; and Central Intelligence Agency, The World Factbook. .
Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

17 17

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Figure A-2. Bayraktar TB2 Drone

Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

18 18

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Figure A-3. Map of U.S. and NATO Military Presence in Turkey

Sources: Department of Defense, NATO, and various media outlets; adapted by CRS. Department of Defense, NATO, and various media outlets; adapted by CRS.
Note: All locations are approximate. All locations are approximate.

Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

19 19

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Figure A-4. Syria-Turkey Border

~~Source~~Sources: CRS, using area of influence data from IHS Jane’s Conflict Monitor. All areas of influence approximate CRS, using area of influence data from IHS Jane’s Conflict Monitor. All areas of influence approximate
and subject to change. Other sources include U.N. OCHA, Esri, and social media reports. and subject to change. Other sources include U.N. OCHA, Esri, and social media reports.
Note: This map does not depict all U.S. bases in Syria. This map does not depict all U.S. bases in Syria.

Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

20 20

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Figure A-5. Competing Claims in the Eastern Mediterranean

Source: Main map created by Main map created by The Economist, with slight modifications by CRS. , with slight modifications by CRS.

Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service

21 21

Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief

Author Information

Jim Zanotti Jim Zanotti
Clayton Thomas Clayton Thomas
Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs
Analyst in Middle Eastern Affairs Analyst in Middle Eastern Affairs

Disclaimer
This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan
shared staff to congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and shared staff to congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and
under the direction of Congress. Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other under the direction of Congress. Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other
than public understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in than public understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in
connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the United States Government, are not connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the United States Government, are not
subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be reproduced and distributed in subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be reproduced and distributed in
its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include copyrighted images or its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include copyrighted images or
material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you wish to material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you wish to
copy or otherwise use copyrighted material. copy or otherwise use copyrighted material.

Congressional Research Service Congressional Research Service
R44000 R44000 · VERSION 6769 · UPDATED
22 22