Trade in the U.S. Gulf Region: Hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Beyond

Trade in the U.S. Gulf Region: Hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Beyond

Order Code RS22332
Updated January 26, 2006
CRS Report for Congress
Received through the CRS Web
Trade in the U.S. Gulf Region: Hurricanes
Katrina, Rita and Beyond
Mary Jane Bolle
Specialist in International Trade
Foreign Affairs, Defense, and Trade Division
Summary
This report examines trade entering and leaving the United States through the Gulf
of Mexico and its 16 major ports — a region extending from southern Florida to
southern Texas. It is designed as a tool for planning or reaction in the 109th Congress,
2nd session, as Congress continues to deal with the hurricanes’ aftermath; and as a
resource to help quickly identify some of the potential trade effects of any other natural
or manmade disaster that might strike the U.S. Gulf coast. Included are five graphs, a
map, and a table summarizing specific trade data for the 16 ports. Finally, this report
looks at potential trade implications of any such disasters and identifies some policy
issues. It will not be updated.1
Purpose of This Report
The Gulf of Mexico can be likened to a gigantic harbor whose span is roughly equal
to one-half the distance between the U.S. Atlantic and Pacific coasts. It is not surprising,
therefore, that roughly 80% of the value of all trade that enters or leaves the United States
along the Gulf coast does so by water.
The strength of the Gulf harbor is that it is somewhat protected and centrally located
for easy water access to Europe and the Mediterranean, Africa, South America, or,
through the Panama Canal, Asia. The problem with the Gulf, however, is that, because
of recent weather changes, it has been the site of increased numbers of higher intensity
hurricanes. These include Hurricane Katrina, which struck the Gulf Coast on August 29,
2005, and Hurricane Rita which struck the Gulf coast on September 24, 2005, temporarily
closing or partially closing five of the 16 trade ports2 and paralyzing the massive network
1 Carolyn Smith and Michael Donnelly, KSG-FDT, CRS, provided statistical assistance.
2 See Table 1 footnotes for a list of ports affected. For other reports on Hurricane Katrina and
its effects on commerce, see CRS Report RL33075, U.S. Agriculture After Hurricane Katrina:
(continued...)
Congressional Research Service ˜ The Library of Congress

CRS-2
of oil and gas facilities, including drilling platforms, pipelines, and refineries. Such
disasters can result in considerable disruption to trade as commodities — some of them
perishable — are delayed, diverted, destroyed, or simply hung up and unable to get
through blocked ports.
The U.S. National Hurricane Center has reported that it expects recent wind and
water temperature changes in the Atlantic Ocean which spawned these more intense
storms to continue — possibly for 25 years or more.3 This report examines trade entering
and leaving the United States through the Gulf of Mexico’s 16 major ports, which
together account for 99% of all Gulf waterborne trade. It is designed as a tool for
planning or reaction — as a resource to help quickly identify some of the potential trade
effects of any natural or manmade disaster that might strike the U.S. Gulf coast. Finally,
this report looks at potential trade implications of any such disasters, and identifies some
policy issues.
Trade Through U.S. Gulf Ports
Along the Gulf lie 16 of the
Figure 1. Composition of Waterborne U.S.
41 largest U.S. ports (see map,
Gulf Trade ($198 billion in Exports and
Figure 6). Houston, the Gulf’s
Imports), 2004
largest, ranks 4th and New
Orleans, the second largest,
ranks 12th in size (based on total
Gulf Trade as % of Composition of
trade value — see Table 1)
Total U.S. Trade
Exports + Imports
among all U.S. ports for
Chemicals - 12%
waterborne trade. Three-
Agriculture - 8%
quarters of imports and exports
of the 16 Gulf ports are from
Oil - 52%
Machinery - 6%
Gulf trade - 9%
three industries: oil, agriculture,
Base metals - 7%
a n d c h e m i c a l s . T h i s
specialization results in large
Textiles,apparel - 3%
Rubber & plastics - 3%
part from geography. Because
Other - 9%
the Gulf area has traditionally
been rich with oil and gas, the
Source: CRS calculations on data from World Trade Atlas. See footnote 4.
processing industry for these
resources grew up around them,
making the Gulf a magnet for additional oil and gas imports. The chemical industry and
many of its products derive, in turn, from crude oil. Symbiotically, they also feed into the
2 (...continued)
Status and Issues, by Randy Schnepf and Ralph Chite; CRS Report RS22257, Hurricane Katrina:
Shipping Disruptions, by John Frittelli; CRS Report RL33124, Oil and Gas Disruption from
Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, by Lawrence Kumins and Robert Bamberger; and CRS Report
RS22297, Ports in Louisiana: New Orleans, South Louisiana, and Baton Rouge, by Vanessa
Cieslak.
3 Interview with meteorologist Stanley Goldenberg of the National Hurricane Center, reported
in Katrina: Why It Became a Man-made Disaster; Where It Could Happen Next, National
Geographic Special edition, fall, 2005, p. 35.

CRS-3
agricultural industry. Agricultural exports through Gulf ports owe their abundance to the
barge-based Mississippi River transportation system, which carries products from at least
16 states cheaply and efficiently, and deposits them in New Orleans or nearby ports.
Overall, (see Figure 1)
Figure 2. Dollar Value of U.S. Gulf Exports
waterborne exports and imports
and Imports, 2004
that pass through U.S. Gulf of
EXPORTS:
IMPORTS:
Mexico ports account for less
$62 billion
$136 billion
than one-tenth of U.S. trade
160
(9%), but a much greater share
140
Chemicals - $7
of the oil (52%), agricultural
Base metals - $13
120
(8%), and chemical (12%)
100
industries. The remaining
quarter of that trade is mostly
80
Oil & gas - $96
Rubber/plastic - $4
machinery, base metals,
60
Machinery - $8
t e x t i l e s / a p p a r e l , a n d
Agriculture - $14
40
Oil & gas - $8
rubber/plastics.4
20
Chemicals -$18
Other - $20
Other - $10
0
Figure 2 shows the relative
Source: CRS calculations on data from World Trade Atlas.
size and composition of U.S.
See footnote 4.
Gulf exports and imports
separately: Imports, at $136
billion in 2004, are more than twice the value of exports, at $62 billion; and oil imports,
at $96 billion clearly dominate Gulf imports (accounting for 70%) and account for nearly
half (48%) of all Gulf trade.
Figure 3. Gulf Port Share of U.S.
Agriculture
Agricultural Exports and Imports, 2004
Industry group
Industry
Commodity
The United States is the
(%)
world’s largest agricultural
Exports
Imports
70
62
64
56
exporter, facilitated by the
60
52
50
41
42
42
37
Mississippi River, which is an
40
30
24 22
19 22
important component of the U.S.’s
16
15
20
9
6
10
c o m p a r a t i v e ad v an t age i n
0
A M Po
Al "
Cor Ri Gr Wh Oi S
A
A Spi Co
Al
ll e
C
oy
l
l
agricultural trade. The river is the
A a u
l v e
ce a e l s
l F
l V c f
l Fa
ni t
lt
r
n
i
be
f
r
e
e
n
a
e
a
e es e
m
y
g

e
e al"
so t
eds an
ts
ge ,
ts
a
t

rg
&
ta c
&
central artery of a 14,500 mile
l
a
s
P
b gr
o
h
a
o
b
ff
o
r
l
a
n
ils
l
i
o
e pr in
u
d
e ee
ls
d
s
m
f

ru
(
p
$
ro , t
($
inland waterway. Its barge traffic
uc
odu
0
e
0
t
it
d
a
s
s
.9
u
.3
(
ct
b
c
b
$0
s
il.
ts
il)
takes agricultural commodities —
.

(
9
($
)

$
b
1
1
i
3

l.)
b
bil
especially grain — down to ocean-
il.)
.)
going vessels in New Orleans and
Source: CRS Calculations on data from World Trade Atlas.
See footnote 4.
South Louisiana, and delivers such
imports as coffee back up the river.
4 All data in this report reflect the Harmonized Tariff Schedule, which groups numerous
commodities into 99 industry classifications which are, in turn, aggregated into 22 separate
industry groups. All data are taken from World Trade Atlas, published by Global Trade
Information Services, Inc. and represent export and import data from the U.S. Census Bureau
manipulated by the U.S. Maritime Administration to reflect waterborne trade.

CRS-4
Each grain-laden barge can carry the equivalent of roughly 15 rail cars or 60 trucks,
at a fraction of the cost of these other modes of transportation. In 2004, agricultural
exports in the Gulf totaled $14 billion. Of this, $13 billion was in vegetable products, and
nearly $1 billion was in animal products. Vegetable exports (see Figure 3) were
dominated by corn (62% of U.S. total), rice (42%), grain sorghum (24%), wheat (22%),
soybeans (64%), and fats and oils (47%). Nearly 40% of all U.S. Gulf “cereal” grain
exports go to four countries: Japan, Mexico, Egypt, and S. Korea. Animal products were
dominated by poultry (mostly frozen) exports, accounting for 37% of all U.S. poultry
exports, much of which goes to Russia.
Oil and Gas
The Gulf of Mexico is one of the great oil and gas production and refining regions
in the world. It is a major region for oil and gas infrastructure, including pipelines, oil and
gas wells, oil and gas platforms, and a refinery at virtually every port. Nearly 60% of all
oil consumed in the United States is imported. Roughly half (see figure 2) of all imported
oil enters the United States through the Gulf — much of it from Mexico, Venezuela,
Saudi Arabia, Nigeria, and Iraq. Primary oil exports are to Mexico and include MBTE,
a gasoline additive/blending component
that has fallen into disfavor in the
Figure 4. Gulf Port Share of U.S.
United States but is used by others
Chemical Exports and Imports, 2004
elsewhere, and such “heavy” products as
Industry group Industry
petroleum coke, which has various uses,
and is something the United States can
(%)
Exports
Imports
70
spare.
57
60
50
43
40
29
30
20
Chemicals
17
19
20
7
10
0
A
f
o
i
A
f
i
l
e
n
e
n
l
r

r
o
l
r
o
c
t
g
r
l c
t
r
The numerous chemical plants in
h
il
a
g
il
g
e
iz
n
a
h
li
a
m
e
i
e
z
r
c
n
m
e
n
i

i
r
i
c
s
ch
c
ic
s
c
the Gulf, particularly along the Texas
a
c
c
l
e
a

h
h
e
m
e
l
e
x
i
m
im
m
p
c
o
al
ic
po
ic
and Louisiana Gulf coasts, account for a
r
s
t
a
r
a
s
ls
t
ls

s
($
(
1
$7
slightly greater share of Gulf exports
8

b
b
i
i
l
l
)
.)
and imports than does agriculture.
Source: CRS calculations on data from World Trade Atlas.
See footnote 4.
Twenty percent of all U.S. chemical
exports exit through Gulf ports (see
Figure 4), including 57% of all
Figure 5. Gulf Port Share of Other
fertilizers, and 43% of all organic
Major U.S. Gulf Exports and Imports,
chemicals, to such countries as S. Korea,
2004
Mexico, and China. Twenty-nine
Industry group Industry
percent of all fertilizer imports enter the
United States through Gulf ports.
(%)
Exports
Imports
50
40
36
40
31
Other
30
22
18
21
18
16
20
13
15 15
12
12
9
10
10
Figure 5 shows other major
0
S
A K C W
A
O
S
C
S
A I
C A Z
t
r
r
ll n o o
l
re
a
o
h
ll o o lu in
products exported through Gulf ports
a

l
i

n
w
te itt tt
r
p
o o
ru
s
t,
k
p
b

p m c
,
e
l
,

s
a
&

x
n
b

s
e i
b
t
d
b
s
u
/f
s
s r n
a
ile o
la
l
lo
e
u
r
er
g
p
a
m te
m
and their share of total such U.S. exports
sk
s

/
,
h
t
e
e
& c
p
a
u
in
e
l
t
r
l
r
t
s
a o
a
s
,
g
a
,
c
s
h
e

l

p
s
s
w
p h
tic
a
t
(
including textiles and apparel: knitted or
i
e
r
r
$
c
a
t
th
u
1
k
re e
,
c
3
e
l d
s
t

r
(
u
$
t
b
o
re
il
crocheted fabrics (21%), cotton products
2
n
.
b
e
s
)
il.)
Source: CRS calculations on data from World Trade Atlas. See footnote 4.

CRS-5
(13%), wool (12%); and straw products (18%). Major products imported through these
ports are base metals (16%), including iron and steel (31%), copper (15%), and aluminum
(15%). These ports also serve as gateways to 40% of all ores, 36% of all vessels entering
the United States (most of them for the oil platforms), 22% of all salt/sulphur, and 18%
of all cork imported into the United States.
Trade Implications and Policy Questions
The extent to which the key U.S. Gulf industries are affected by disasters in the Gulf
area depends on which ports and industry infrastructures are affected. The 16 key ports
in the Gulf of Mexico are depicted below in map form (Figure 6) and in table form
(Table 1). For each port, Table 1 lists (column 1) the name of the port and its ranking
(based on total exports and imports) among all U.S. ports; the total 2004 trade value
(column 2); the total value of that port’s exports together with major exports and their
share of that port’s total (column 3); and the total value of that port’s imports together
with major imports and their share of that port’s total (column 4).
If some ports are damaged, products can be shipped out of the country through other
ports, but transportation costs may increase and perishable commodities may be lost.
Although Figure 6 shows commodity specialization, by port, many ports export high
volumes of key commodities. All 16 ports except Gulfport handle oil as an export or
import and typically include refineries. All 16 ports export chemicals although only 10
specialize in chemical exports. Most grain exports pass through Texas or Louisiana.
Only Pascagoula specializes in exporting poultry, although sizable quantities of poultry
(not shown in table 1) also pass through Mobile, New Orleans Gulf Port, or Houston.
Gulfport specializes in textile and apparel exports.
Hurricane Katrina closed or partially closed five main Gulf ports: New Orleans,
South Louisiana, Mobile, Pascagoula, and Gulfport. Hurricane Rita affected two:
Beaumont and Galveston. Most ports were quickly reopened. While some goods found
other import or export routes, some oil production facilities have still not reopened at the
time this report was published. Currently, monthly statistics on waterborne trade in U.S.
Gulf ports are lagging economic activity by at least seven months. Thus, statistics from
which to estimate changes in the value of exports and imports as a result of these
hurricanes will likely not be available until about mid-2006. Meanwhile, the U.S. Census
Bureau has begun releasing preliminary export and import data for all Gulf ports covering
months since Hurricanes Katrina and Rita struck; however, these data have not been
further refined by the U.S. Maritime Administration. These data are available at
[http://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/Press-Release/gulf_index.html]. With data from
either source, however, it may be hard to separate out effects of Katrina from other effects
such as overall weather and supply and demand — especially on agricultural products,
which may vary considerably in tonnage and value from year to year.
The potential for additional hurricanes in the Gulf region in the coming years raises
a number of trade policy questions. Some of the most important ones revolve around
options for protecting the trade infrastructure, which includes the Mississippi River, grain
storage elevators, the various ports, oil facilities in the Gulf of Mexico, and U.S. merchant
vessels.

CRS-6
Table 1. Commodity Specialization by Port: Waterborne Exports
and Imports
(all $ in millions)
U.S. Gulf of Mexico Port
and rank (total trade
Total 2004 exports, Major EXPORTS
Total 2004 imports, Major
value) among all U.S.
Total 2004
and share of total Port exports for each IMPORTS and share of total Port
ports
trade value
industry
imports for each industry
4. Houston, TX
$29,064 (mil.): chemicals (32%),
$36,835 (mil.): oil (48%), base
$65,899
machinery (23%), oil (11%)
metals (14%), chemicals (9%)
*12. New Orleans, LA
$9,579: vegetable products (37%),
$12,592: base metals (37%), oil
$22,171
chemicals (23%), oil (12%)
(24%), chemicals (9%)
15. Morgan City, LA
$143: machinery (51%) floating
$14,134: oil (100%)
$14,277
vessels/docks (29%),
*16. S. Louisiana
$7,644: vegetable prods. (cereals and oil
$6,541: oil (73%)
$14,185
seeds) (79%)
**18. Beaumont, TX
$1,295: oil (51%), chemicals (32%),
$11,992: oil (98%)
$13,287
cereals (15%)
20. Corpus Christi, TX
$2,043: chemicals (48%), oil (32%)
$9,920: oil (93%)
$11,963
vegetable. prods. (13%)
22. Texas City, TX
$8,629
$1,423: inorganic chemicals (75%)
$7,206: oil (99%)
24. Port Arthur, TX
$7,219
$724: oil (63%), chemicals (27%)
$6,495: oil (94%)
25. Freeport, TX
$1,434: chemicals (62%), rubber/plastic
$5,727: oil (94%)
$7,161
(24%)
27. Baton Rouge, LA
$6,693
$1,274: chemicals (76%), oil (19%)
$5,419: oil (68%), iron/steel (18%)
31. Lake Charles, LA
$6,055
$806: oil (40%), chemicals (34%)
$5,249: oil (98%)
*33. Mobile, AL
$1,694: wood pulp (24%), oil (23%),
$3,431: oil (56%), base metals
$5,125
chemicals (14%)
(18%)
*35. Pascagoula, MS
$764: poultry (29%), machinery (26%),
$3,878: oil (94%)
$4,642
oil (22%)
*37. Gulfport, MS
$1,622: textiles/apparel (60%), wood pulp $2,355: textiles & apparel (78%)
$3,977
(11%), machinery (8%), poultry (8%)
**40. Galveston, TX
$703: cereals (49%), machinery (14%), oil $2,586: oil (67%), machinery (15%)
$3,289
(11%)
41. Tampa FL
$1,735: fertilizer (85%)
$1,462: inorganic chemicals (35%),
$3,197
oil (15%); vehicles (15%)
Total: Gulf Ports
$197,769
$61,947
$135,822
Source: CRS calculations on U.S. Customs data manipulated by the U.S. Maritime Administration.
*Ports closed or partly closed by Hurricane Katrina.
** Ports closed or partly closed by Hurricane Rita.
Figure 6. Sixteen Key Ports in the U.S. Gulf of Mexico