China-India Rivalry in the Indian Ocean

China-India Rivalry in the Indian Ocean

August 16, 2017
China-India Rivalry in the Indian Ocean
Rivalry between China and India, the world’s two most
ships. China also reportedly leased an island in the
populous nations, appears to be increasing. While tensions
Maldives to develop Maritime Silkroad infrastructure. In
over the two nations’ disputed border and other diplomatic
addition, in July 2017, China sent troops to Djibouti to set
frictions have attracted attention in recent months, the
up its first-ever overseas military base. The base will
China-India rivalry is also expanding into the Indian Ocean.
reportedly support Chinese naval ships operating in the
Congress may consider the implications of this evolving
region. Djibouti’s location on the Horn of Africa gives it
strategic rivalry for U.S. interests and strategic balances of
access to the strategic Bab el-Mandeb Strait, which
Asia.
connects the Mediterranean Sea with the Indian Ocean via
the Suez Canal. A 2016 U.S. Defense Department report to
Indian Ocean Background
Congress states that China’s “military modernization
The Indian Ocean region (IOR) was a center of strategic
program has become more focused on supporting missions
competition for European colonial powers, including the
beyond China’s periphery, including power projection [and]
Portuguese, Dutch, French, and British. The British East
sea lane security ... China most likely will seek to establish
India Company’s presence in the subcontinent is one
additional military bases in countries with which it has a
example of this. China and other Asian powers have also
longstanding friendly relationship and similar strategic
played a role in the IOR. The voyages of Zheng He (1405-
interests, such as Pakistan.”
1433), for example, briefly extended Chinese influence into
the Indian Ocean. The economic rise of China, India, and
Figure 1.Indo-Pacific Energy and Trade Routes
other Asian nations, and the rapid associated growth in
seaborne trade and energy that transits the Indian Ocean, is
making the region increasingly significant. Approximately
50% of the world’s container traffic and 70% of its
petroleum shipments transit the Indian Ocean. The Indian
Ocean littoral region encompassed 2.49 billion people in
2010, representing more than one-third of the world’s
population. It is estimated that by 2030 the population in
the IOR will have expanded by 27%. An estimated 15% of
the world’s fish catch comes from the Indian Ocean, and it
may have additional hydrocarbon reserves that may further
increase its strategic importance.
China’s Expanding Presence in the IOR
China’s developing strategic presence in the IOR is
manifesting itself largely through port and infrastructure
projects, and through its first regional military base. China’s
development and investment projects have gained strategic

coherence through Beijing’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).
Source: CRS map by Hannah Fischer with data from the South China Morning
This initiative is intended to develop trade and energy
Post (2017); the Department of State (2015); Esri (2016); DeLorme (2016).
routes through the Indian Ocean and its littoral. The BRI’s
most high-profile project is the $46 billion China-Pakistan
Analysts believe the China-India rivalry could spur the
Economic Corridor designed to link China’s west through
more rapid development and deployment of naval assets on
Pakistan to Pakistan’s Gwadar Port on the Arabian Sea.
both sides, and in the region more broadly. This geographic
China has also proposed a Bangladesh-China-India-
expansion of strategic competition between China and India
Myanmar (BCIM) Economic Corridor. The Kunming-
may increase strategic linkages between the Asia-Pacific
Kyaukpyu, Burma segment of the BCIM has moved
and the Indian Ocean regions, creating a larger, increasingly
forward. China is rebuilding its ties with Burma and may
interactive Indo-Pacific region including increased
augment its oil and gas linkages with that country by
competition for energy and other resources across the IOR.
developing a Special Economic Zone at Kyaukpyu on the
Bay of Bengal. China has agreed to sell submarines to
The potential for increasing competition with China may
Bangladesh and Pakistan and has also invested heavily in
add impetus in India to further develop its relationship with
port facilities and other infrastructure in Hambantota,
the United States and/or other regional partners in the Indo-
Colombo, and elsewhere in Sri Lanka. China is developing
Pacific, such as Japan and Australia. Great power
investments in port, rail, and pipeline projects in Malaysia,
competition may also offer opportunities for Indian Ocean
including at Melaka, Selankor, and Perak. Malaysia
littoral states to gain foreign aid, military assistance, and
recently agreed to purchase four Chinese littoral mission
possibly trade and investment. The expansion of Indian and
Chinese naval capabilities and presence and increased
https://crsreports.congress.gov

China-India Rivalry in the Indian Ocean
engagement with regional states could diminish the relative
Tensions at Dokalam appeared to be easing in early
strategic posture of the United States in the IOR.
September 2017.
China-India dynamics in this region have further
Economic factors also influence to some extent relations
implications for U.S. interests and policy. The IOR is a
between India and China. In 2016, India had a $51.1 billion
crucial transit route for energy and other cargoes shipped
trade deficit with China although China’s exports to India
between the Middle East and East Asia’s booming
accounted for only 2% of China’s total exports. Chinese
economies. This strategic importance is one factor behind
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in India has grown rapidly
rising naval procurement by India, China, and their
in recent years. China’s rank as a source of FDI in India has
neighbors, and has led to greater Chinese naval activity in
risen from 28th in 2014 to 17th in 2016.
the IOR. China’s economic, diplomatic, and military
expansion into the region is widely viewed as a challenge
Strategic Implications
for India, long the region’s dominant power, and may be
Much of the Indian Ocean is within the U.S. Navy’s
leading to a more outward-looking foreign policy in New
Seventh Fleet’s area of responsibility. The United States
Delhi, and to warming U.S.-India relations in recent years.
military has air, naval, and logistics hubs on the island of
The extensive U.S. naval presence in the Indian Ocean and
Diego Garcia and in Djibouti. The fight against Al Qaeda
adjacent waters—along with U.S. diplomatic and economic
and the Islamic State in Afghanistan and Iraq has increased
relations with the nations that rely on these transit routes—
the strategic importance of the IOR for the United States as
also makes these dynamics directly relevant to U.S.
large numbers of U.S. military personnel have deployed
interests. One issue for Congress is whether to hold
through the region in recent years. The region’s energy and
hearings on this issue to help the administration develop a
trade routes are of strategic importance to the United States
comprehensive and integrated strategy toward the Indian
and many other nations. Any disruption of the strategic sea
Ocean or the Indo-Pacific more broadly. Another issue for
lanes that link the energy-rich Persian Gulf with the energy-
Congress is whether to take into account this rivalry when
dependent economies of Asia would be detrimental to the
considering naval procurement, or reviewing defense
world’s economy. Increasing U.S. energy independence
planning and multilateral cooperation in the region.
makes it relatively less vulnerable to interruption of these
routes than other nations. China’s dependence on imported
General Context of China-India Rivalry
energy, and the strategic vulnerability that this presents, has
Bilateral tensions between India and China related to border
been labeled its “Malacca dilemma” after the key strategic
disputes and China’s support of Pakistan have existed for
strait through which an estimated 80% of Chinese oil
many years. China and India fought a brief border war in
imports flow. Much of China’s strategic maneuvering in the
the Himalayas in 1962. This was generally considered a
IOR can be viewed as an attempt to minimize this
humiliating defeat for India and left a disputed border.
vulnerability.
While India and China have in the past sought to negotiate
a settlement of the border, China in recent years has made
The extension of Chinese influence into South Asia and the
more assertive claims. Since 2006, China has claimed the
IOR, when viewed in the context of China’s assertive
Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh as the Chinese territory
behavior in the East China Sea and the South China Sea,
of “South Tibet.” China also holds significant territory in
raises concerns in many Asian capitals. China’s
the western sector of the border at Aksai Chin.
contemporary naval presence in the Indian Ocean began
with counterpiracy operations in the Arabian Sea. While
From India’s perspective, ongoing tensions have been
some in India increasingly feel encircled by China’s
exacerbated by China’s opposition to India’s joining the
strategic moves in the region, the Chinese may also feel
Nuclear Suppliers Group, its obstruction of efforts to
threatened by its limited ability to secure sea lanes, upon
designate Jaish-e-Muhammad leader Masood Azhar a
which China’s economy depends for both trade and energy.
terrorist at the United Nations, Chinese and Pakistani plans
The Chinese also emphasize the potential economic
to develop the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)
benefits of the Belt and Road Initiative to regional states.
through part of Kashmir claimed by India but held by
Understanding and effectively managing these evolving
Pakistan, and China’s growing ties with and presence in
security and economic issues may be key to preserving
Indian Ocean littoral states. A further strengthening of
regional stability and U.S. interests in the region. Some IOR
China-Pakistan ties could have a negative impact on China-
states are hedging against China’s rising power or
India relations given India’s and Pakistan’s historically
developing their own defense capabilities; others are
adversarial relationship. A 2017 Pew poll in India found
seeking more accommodative strategies or combining these
that 44% of Indians felt that China posed a threat to India.
approaches. Hedging strategies by Asian states include both
India has shown some reluctance to antagonize China as
developing intra-Asian strategic ties as well as enhanced
possibly demonstrated by its reported decision to decline
ties between regional states and the United States. From this
Australia’s request to join the 2017 Malabar naval exercise
perspective there may be an opportunity for enhanced
among India, the United States, and Japan. From China’s
security collaboration between and among democratic
perspective, issues contributing to bilateral tensions include
nations such as the United States, India, Australia, and
the visit by Tibet’s exiled spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama,
Japan.
to the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh, which China
considers disputed territory; India’s decision not to attend
Bruce Vaughn, Specialist in Asian Affairs
China’s Belt and Road initiative summit in May 2017; and
IF10726
a recent stand-off between Chinese and Indian soldiers at
Dokalam, an area disputed between Bhutan and China.
https://crsreports.congress.gov

China-India Rivalry in the Indian Ocean

Disclaimer
This document was prepared by the Congressional Research Service (CRS). CRS serves as nonpartisan shared staff to
congressional committees and Members of Congress. It operates solely at the behest of and under the direction of Congress.
Information in a CRS Report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public understanding of information that has
been provided by CRS to Members of Congress in connection with CRS’s institutional role. CRS Reports, as a work of the
United States Government, are not subject to copyright protection in the United States. Any CRS Report may be
reproduced and distributed in its entirety without permission from CRS. However, as a CRS Report may include
copyrighted images or material from a third party, you may need to obtain the permission of the copyright holder if you
wish to copy or otherwise use copyrighted material.

https://crsreports.congress.gov | IF10726 · VERSION 2 · NEW